By Jim AkinCash vs. Credit Card: Which Should I Use?
By Jim Akin
Deciding whether to make a payment using cash or a credit card used to be fairly simple: You'd typically only use credit when a purchase required more cash than you had on hand. The choice is more nuanced today, thanks to improved card-user benefits and changes in the way we shop. Here's an overview of the considerations, and some advice on when to use each.
Research on Americans' use of cash and credit cards found cash usage in decline:
- The Federal Reserve's annual Consumer Payment Choice Diary, published in October 2020, found that cash use accounted for 19% of all payments, a drop of 7 percentage points from 2019.
- A survey conducted by Travis Credit Union published in September 2020 found that just 29% of Americans prefer using cash alone to make conduct payments, and that twice as many (59%) prefer using credit or debit cards exclusively, in lieu of cash. While a majority of respondents (52%) cited convenience as the main reason they prefer card payments, 11% said they prefer cards because they are more hygienic than cash.
Despite the growing popularity of non-cash options, Experian research compiled in the third quarter of 2020 found that consumers are making inroads to reducing their credit card debt. Experian found overall outstanding consumer credit card debt in the U.S. debt fell 9% since 2019. The average credit card debt per consumer fell as well, by 14% to $5,315. Along with the reduction in debt levels, the average number of credit cards American consumers hold dipped to 3.84.
Pros and Cons of Cash and Credit Cards
These are the main points to consider when deciding whether to pay with cash or a credit card:
| Credit Card | Cash |
|---|---|
| Accepted nearly everywhere | Universally accepted |
| User is protected from unauthorized charges if the card is lost or stolen | Difficult or impossible to recover if lost or stolen |
| Potentially vulnerable to fraud | Physical cash, debit cards and checks are subject to theft and abuse; bank accounts are vulnerable to electronic fraud |
| Allows contactless payments at a growing number of locations; easy to sanitize | Cash may be dirty, germy or otherwise unpleasant to handle; difficult to sanitize |
| Many cards can be used internationally, enabling payments to be made in local currencies | Cash must be exchanged for local currency in most foreign locations |
| Usage of rewards cards may accrue cash, purchase points, or other goods and services rewards | Discounts are available on cash purchases from some merchants, including gas stations |
When You Should Use a Credit Card Over Cash
Instances when it makes sense to use a credit card instead of cash include the following situations.
- When making purchases online, by phone or through a catalog, especially when the product is unfamiliar to you, a credit card can help you avoid buyer's remorse. If the merchandise isn't all you hoped it would be, or if it arrives damaged, your credit card company can assist you to ensure you get a replacement or a refund.
- If you get cash back, airline miles or other rewards benefits from your card, you can benefit by using your card for everyday purchases (groceries, fuel and so on), as long as you aren't carrying a balance on that card and can pay off those charges in full and on time each month. If you carry a balance on the card, interest charges can quickly offset the value of any rewards you might accumulate.
- If you're working to improve or rebuild your credit, using your credit card(s) regularly for small purchases and paying your full balance on time every month can help. Each timely payment adds a positive entry to your payment history, which is the most influential factor that determines your credit scores.
Best credit cards of 2026
Compare cards from our partners with intro bonuses, cash back or points offers, and annual fees as low as $0.
Offers from our partners
Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express
Intro bonus:As High As $200 Cash Back. Find Out Your Offer.
Intro APR:0% on Purchases and Balance Transfers for 15 months
Ongoing APR:19.49%-28.49% Variable
Rewards:1% - 3% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$0
Wells Fargo Reflect® Card
Intro APR:0% intro APR for 21 months from account opening on purchases and qualifying balance transfers
Ongoing APR:17.49%, 23.99%, or 28.24% Variable APR
Rewards:N/A*
Annual Fee:$0
Discover it® Chrome
Intro bonus:Cashback Match™
Intro APR:0% intro APR for 6 Months on Purchases and 0% intro APR for 18 Months on Balance Transfers
Ongoing APR:17.49% - 26.49% Variable APR
Rewards:1% - 2% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$0
Revel® Platinum Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:35.90% Fixed
Rewards:N/A*
Annual Fee:$75 - $125
American Express Platinum Card®
Intro bonus:As high as 175,000 points. Find out your offer.
Ongoing APR:See Pay Over Time APR
Rewards:1x - 5x (Points per dollar)
Annual Fee:$895
Discover it® Cash Back
Intro bonus:Cashback Match™
Intro APR:0% intro APR for 15 months on Purchases and Balance Transfers
Ongoing APR:17.49% - 26.49% Variable APR
Rewards:1% - 5% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$0
FIT™ Platinum Mastercard® - $400 Credit Limit
Ongoing APR:35.90% Fixed
Rewards:N/A*
Annual Fee:$99 first year; $125 thereafter
The opensky® Secured Visa® Credit Card
Ongoing APR:23.89% Variable
Rewards:10% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$35
Reflex® Platinum Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:35.90% Fixed
Rewards:N/A*
Annual Fee:$75 - $125
American Airlines AAdvantage® MileUp® Card
Intro APR:0% for 15 months on Balance Transfers
Ongoing APR:19.49% - 29.49% (Variable)
Rewards:2x (Miles per dollar)
Annual Fee:$0
Avant® Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:35.99%*
Rewards:N/A*
Annual Fee:$0*
Avant® Cashback Rewards Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:35.99%*
Rewards:1% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$0*
American Express® Gold Card
Intro bonus:As high as 100,000 points. Find out your offer.
Ongoing APR:See Pay Over Time APR
Rewards:1x - 4x (Points per dollar)
Annual Fee:$325
First Latitude Secured Mastercard® Cash Back Rewards
Ongoing APR:27.49% Variable
Rewards:1% - 10% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$0
Avant® Cashback Rewards Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:35.99%*
Rewards:1% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$75*
Citi® / AAdvantage® Globe™ Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:19.49% - 29.49% (Variable)
Rewards:1x - 6x (Miles per dollar)
Annual Fee:$350
Avant® Cashback Rewards Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:35.99%*
Rewards:1% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$39*
Credit One Bank® Platinum X5 Visa® Metal Card
Ongoing APR:29.74% Variable
Rewards:1% - 5% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$95
Credit One Bank® Premier American Express® Credit Card
Ongoing APR:29.74% Variable
Rewards:1% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$39
Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant® American Express® Card
Intro bonus:200,000 Points
Ongoing APR:19.49%-28.49% Variable
Rewards:2x - 6x (Points per dollar)
Annual Fee:$650
Discover it® Miles
Intro bonus:Discover Match®
Intro APR:0% intro APR for 15 months on Purchases and Balance Transfers
Ongoing APR:17.49% - 26.49% Variable APR
Rewards:1.5x (Miles per dollar)
Annual Fee:$0
Delta SkyMiles® Gold American Express Card
Intro bonus:70,000 Miles
Ongoing APR:19.49%-28.49% Variable
Rewards:1x - 2x (Miles per dollar)
Annual Fee:$0 introductory annual fee for the first year, then $150.
Credit One Bank® Premier American Express® Unlimited Rewards Card
Ongoing APR:29.74% Variable
Rewards:1% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$0
Hilton Honors American Express Surpass® Card
Intro bonus:130,000 Points
Ongoing APR:19.49%-28.49% Variable
Rewards:3x - 12x (Points per dollar)
Annual Fee:$150
Delta SkyMiles® Blue American Express Card
Intro bonus:10,000 Miles
Ongoing APR:19.49%-28.49% Variable
Rewards:1x - 2x (Miles per dollar)
Annual Fee:$0
Marriott Bonvoy Bevy® American Express® Card
Intro bonus:175,000 Points
Ongoing APR:19.49%-28.49% Variable
Rewards:2x - 6x (Points per dollar)
Annual Fee:$250
PREMIER Bankcard® Mastercard® Credit Card
Ongoing APR:See Rates & Fees
Rewards:N/A*
Annual Fee:See Rates & Fees
One Key™ Card
Intro bonus:$300
Ongoing APR:18.49%, 23.49%, or 28.49% Variable APR
Rewards:1.5x - 3x (Points per dollar)
Annual Fee:$0
Avant® Cashback Rewards Mastercard® - With A Higher Credit Limit
Ongoing APR:35.99%*
Rewards:1% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$125*
Avant® Cashback Rewards Mastercard®
Ongoing APR:35.99%*
Rewards:1% (cash back)
Annual Fee:$0*
See all our best credit cards for 2026.
When You Should Use Cash Over a Credit Card
The main benefits of making payments with cash are straightforward.
- Limiting yourself to spending only the cash you have on hand during a night out, weekend away or any other occasion can make it harder to overspend or run up credit card purchases that'll lead to costly interest charges. Sticking only to cash takes discipline, but a bit of organization can help as well. Separating your money into daily or nightly "allowances" can help you stretch your vacation fund, for example.
- The protections against overspending are much the same whether you're reaching into your wallet for cash or a debit card or you're making cash payments from your checking account via a smartphone app such as Venmo, Zelle, or a digital wallet such as Apple Pay or Google Pay. If an app or debit card is your preference, be sure to pay close attention to your available balance: If the account linked to your app has overdraft protection, your financial institution might let you spend more than you have in the account, then charge you a fee for doing so.
- Paying cash sometimes earns you a discount as well. Independent merchants such as gas station owners may offer discounts on cash purchases to dissuade customers from using credit cards (which charge fees to merchants on each purchase).
Choosing between paying with cash or a credit card isn't a life-or-death decision, but using each payment method appropriately can help you get the greatest benefit out of your credit cards, without paying more interest than you should.
Don’t apply blindly
Apply for credit cards confidently with personalized offers based on your credit profile. Get started with your FICO® Score for free.
See your offers
About the author
Jim Akin
Jim Akin is freelance writer based in Connecticut. With experience as both a journalist and a marketing professional, his most recent focus has been in the area of consumer finance and credit scoring.
Read more from Jim