Cash Back vs. Points: Which Rewards Credit Card Is Better?

How Does Cash Back Work?

Cash back credit cards reward you with a percentage of your spending returned to you as cash. When you make a purchase, you earn a certain percentage back—typically ranging from 1% to 6% depending on the purchase category and card.

The mechanics are straightforward: You use your card to make purchases, and the card issuer calculates your cash back based on your spending. Some cards offer a flat rate on all purchases, while others provide higher rates in specific categories like groceries, gas or dining. Certain cards rotate their bonus categories quarterly, requiring you to activate them to earn the higher rate.

Once you've earned cash back, you can redeem it in several ways. Most issuers let you apply it as a statement credit to reduce your balance, deposit it directly into a bank account or use it for purchases at checkout. Some may also offer other redemption options, such as gift cards, shopping or online travel.

Earn rewards for your spending

1Sign up for free

See your top credit card matches based on your credit profile and spending habits.

2Choose your rewards card

Get the right card to earn cash back or points on your purchases and maximize your perks.

3Apply with confidence

Apply for rewards cards matched for you and that you’re more likely to qualify for.

See your offers

Pros and Cons of Cash Back

Cash back rewards offer a straightforward approach to earning from your spending, but they come with trade-offs worth considering.

Learn more: The Best Ways to Redeem Credit Card Rewards

How Do Credit Card Points Work?

Credit card points programs reward your spending with points that can be redeemed for various options, most commonly travel. When you make a purchase, you earn points based on your spending. Depending on the card, you may earn a flat rewards rate on all of your purchases or tiered rewards based on your spending categories.

General rewards programs are tied to the card issuer and can be redeemed within their ecosystem or travel portal. Co-branded programs partner with specific airlines or hotels, earning points directly in those loyalty programs.

Unlike with cash back cards, the value of credit card points can vary significantly based on how you redeem them. For example, some programs let you redeem points for statement credits, travel or gift cards, typically at a value of 1 cent per point or less.

However, when you transfer points to airline and hotel partners, they can deliver significantly more value, sometimes reaching 1.5 to 2 cents per point or higher.

Pros and Cons of Points

Points programs offer powerful earning potential but require more active management to maximize their value. Here's what to consider before you apply for a points credit card.

Learn more: Is It Worth Paying an Annual Fee for a Credit Card?

Cash Back vs. Points: Which Should You Choose?

The right rewards structure depends on your lifestyle, spending habits and willingness to optimize redemptions. Consider these scenarios to guide your decision.

When to Choose Cash Back

• You value simplicity. If you prefer straightforward rewards without researching redemption strategies, cash back delivers instant, predictable value with minimal effort.
• You want maximum flexibility. Cash back isn't tied to specific merchants, travel dates or redemption windows. You can use it however you want, whenever you want.
• You rarely travel. Without regular flights or hotel stays to redeem points for, cash back provides better practical value than points sitting unused in your account.
• You want to avoid an annual fee. Many excellent cash back cards charge no annual fee, making them ideal if you want to minimize costs while earning rewards.
• You prefer consistent value. With cash back, you always know what you're earning. There's no risk of devaluations or complex redemption math to navigate.

When to Choose Points

• You travel frequently. If you fly several times per year or stay in hotels regularly, points cards can deliver substantially more value through travel redemptions than cash back.
• You're willing to strategize redemptions. Points programs reward active management. If you enjoy researching award availability and transfer partners, you can extract exceptional value.
• You want premium experiences. Points enable access to business-class flights, luxury hotels and other high-end travel that could be financially unrealistic if paying cash.
• You have significant spending. Higher annual fees on points cards require substantial spending to break even. If your monthly expenses are considerable, the additional earning rates and benefits can justify the cost.
• You value travel perks beyond rewards. Premium points cards often include benefits like airport lounge access, travel statement credits and travel insurance that can offset annual fees even before considering points value.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Bottom Line

Choosing between cash back and points isn't about finding the objectively best option. Rather, it's about matching rewards to your lifestyle. Cash back delivers simplicity and flexibility, while points offer the potential for premium experiences at higher value.

Your decision should reflect how you spend, whether you travel and how much time you're willing to invest in maximizing rewards. Many people benefit from having both types of cards in their wallet, using cash back for everyday spending and points for travel-related expenses.

Whichever path you choose, remember that rewards are only valuable if you're using your credit card responsibly. Paying interest on a balance will quickly erase any rewards you earn, so always pay your statement balance in full each month.

If you want to explore some options, Experian can help you compare credit cards based on your credit profile and find the right rewards program for your needs.