Why Did My Collision Car Insurance Rates Go Up?

Light bulb icon.

Quick Answer

  • Your collision insurance rate can rise for reasons you control, like an at-fault accident or a lost discount.
  • An increase can also be the result of broader economic trends like costlier repairs and higher vehicle prices.
  • To find out why your rate went up, compare your new declarations page with your previous one, or simpler yet, ask your agent.
A young shocked woman looking at mobile phone.

Car insurance rates fell 5.1% over the past 12 months ending in August 2026, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). That may come as a surprise if your auto insurance rates have recently increased.

So why did your premiums increase? Your collision car insurance rates likely went up because of a recent at-fault accident, higher vehicle repair costs or general inflation affecting insurance markets. Here's why your auto collision insurance rates may be high and some tips to save on car insurance.

What Causes Collision Insurance Rates to Increase?

Your rate for collision insurance can go up because of personal factors or broader trends in the insurance industry, or both.

Personal Factors

Some factors impacting your rates are based on details about you, your car or your coverage.

  • At-fault accident: Your rates are almost certain to go up if you're determined to be at fault for an accident, as insurers generally view this type of accident as a greater risk of future claims.
  • Not-at-fault accident: If your state permits it, insurers may consider your overall accident history and raise your rates even if you didn't cause the accident.
  • Driving record: A history of traffic tickets and moving violations could drive up your rates. Rates can jump significantly if you have several violations on your record.
  • Loss of discounts: Your car insurance rate will increase if you lose a discount for any reason. For example, an accident or speeding ticket could result in the loss of a safe driving discount and push your premiums up.
  • Adding a car or driver: Every car on your policy has its own collision premium, so adding a new vehicle to your policy will drive up your costs. Adding a driver can also increase your auto insurance premium, especially if the new driver is a teenager. Teen drivers generally cost more to insure because of their inexperience and higher risk of accidents. Crash rates for teen drivers are over four times those of drivers 20 and older, according to Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) data.
  • Moving to a new area: Insurers consider your location when setting insurance premiums. If you recently moved to an area with more accident claims, that may explain why your collision car insurance rate is higher.

Industry and Economic Trends

Even with a spotless driving record, your collision premium can go up for reasons beyond your control, such as:

  • Higher repair costs: Vehicles have more technology, including cameras and sensors, than ever before, so even a minor crash can lead to substantial repair costs.
  • Inflation: When the costs of auto parts, labor and cars themselves rise, the insurance cost to repair and replace them also goes up. The BLS reports that motor vehicle maintenance and repair prices increased 5.2% over the 12 months ending in August 2026.
  • Local risk increases: Auto insurance companies base premiums partly on claim costs in your area. If those costs have gone up, so, too, might your collision insurance rates.
  • Rising vehicle values: New and used cars now cost an average of $50,089 and $27,239, respectively, according to August 2026 figures from Kelley Blue Book. The used car average is the highest it's been since December 2022. Since collision coverage pays to replace your car at its current value, a more valuable car costs your insurer more to replace, which could lead to higher premiums.
  • More accidents: Over 6.18 million crashes were reported to police in 2024, up slightly from 2023, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Even if your driving record is accident-free, your insurer factors in its overall claims costs into your collision rate.

Learn more: Factors That Affect Your Car Insurance Rates

How to Find Out Why Your Collision Insurance Went Up

Follow these tips to determine why your collision insurance rates increased:

  • Call your agent. The quickest way to find out why your collision rate went up is to simply ask your agent what led to the change. Your agent should be able to give you specifics, such as whether it was due to a personal reason, like a speeding ticket, or broader industry economics, such as inflation.
  • Ask for code details. If your renewal notice includes any unfamiliar codes, ask your agent to define them and whether they impacted your rate. Ask for a written explanation of the reasons for the rate increase and how much each listed factor added to your premium.
  • Review your account. Compare your renewal declaration page with the one from your last policy to see what changed. For example, look for changes in the number of drivers or vehicles on the policy, deductibles, mileage usage and discounts.
  • Check driving and claims records. Your driving record and the miles you drive are two primary factors impacting your insurance rates. Make sure your insurer's records of accidents, traffic violations, mileage and claims are correct so you don't pay more because of an error.

What Does Collision Insurance Cover?

Collision insurance helps to pay for expensive damage your car sustains in an accident, including:

  • Car-to-car crashes: If you cause an accident with another vehicle, your collision insurance can pay for damage to your vehicle.
  • Hitting stationary objects: Your coverage also pays to repair your car if you collide with a tree, fence, telephone pole or other stationary object.
  • Rollover accidents: If your car flips and rolls over, it's good to know collision insurance can help cover your repair or replacement costs.
  • Hit-and-run damage: Collision insurance also covers you if another vehicle hits your vehicle and flees the scene.
  • Pothole damage: Potholes can cause serious damage to your car's steering, suspension, tires and wheels. Collision coverage can help you pay for repair costs.

What Doesn't Collision Insurance Cover?

While collision insurance can help pay for damage from a car accident, it doesn't cover everything. Here are some examples of incidents collision insurance doesn't cover:

  • Weather and natural disasters: Collision insurance doesn't pay for damages from hail, falling tree branches and other weather-related events. These losses are covered by comprehensive auto insurance.
  • Damage to another driver's vehicle: Collision insurance only covers the costs to repair or replace your car, not another vehicle in an accident.
  • Theft and vandalism: Since these incidents aren't collisions, they aren't covered by collision insurance but rather comprehensive insurance.
  • Medical care: Collision insurance covers your vehicle only, so medical bills for you or someone else aren't covered.
  • Collision with an animal: Colliding with an animal is generally covered by comprehensive coverage, not collision insurance.

Do I Need Collision Insurance?

Drivers aren't legally required to buy collision insurance in any state. But if you lease or finance your vehicle, the lender typically requires full coverage car insurance, which includes both comprehensive and collision coverage. Carrying collision insurance could make financial sense if you have a high-value vehicle to protect against high repair costs. It can also protect your savings from out-of-pocket repair costs after an accident.

But paying for collision insurance may be less necessary if your car is only worth a few thousand dollars, or if its value is only marginally higher than your deductible. You also may not need it if you can comfortably afford repair costs after an accident.

Learn more: How Much Car Insurance Do I Need?

How to Save on Car Insurance

Costs for collision insurance can vary by insurer, but thankfully, there are steps you can take to lower your auto insurance premiums, such as:

  • Increase your deductible. Your deductible, which typically ranges from $0 to $2,500, is the amount you pay from your own funds before your insurance coverage kicks in. Generally, higher deductibles result in premium savings, but understand you'll pay more out of pocket when you make a claim.
  • Reduce coverage you don't need. Review your coverages before renewal to make sure they still fit your needs and eliminate or reduce unnecessary costs. For example, you may not need roadside assistance insurance if your auto club or credit card already covers it.
  • Look into accident forgiveness. Ask your insurer if they offer accident forgiveness insurance, which is typically an optional add-on that can help you avoid a premium hike the first time you cause an accident.
  • Choose the right vehicle. The type of vehicle you drive significantly impacts the price you pay for car insurance. Lower-priced economy cars have more affordable premiums since their replacement parts are typically less costly than those of more expensive luxury cars.
  • Scoop up discounts. Ask your agent which car insurance discounts you qualify for that can help lower your rate. For example, you can get a lower rate for bundling your homeowners and auto insurance policies with the same insurer and for insuring more than one vehicle with the company. Also check for lesser-known discounts, such as for parking your car inside a garage.
  • Shop and compare providers. The Insurance Information Institute recommends comparing policies from at least three providers. Shopping different providers can help you dial in the scope of coverage you want at the best available price. You may streamline the process by utilizing an online comparison option like Experian's auto insurance comparison platform. Provide some basic information about yourself and your vehicle once to view multiple car insurance quotes side by side.

Frequently Asked Questions

There's no set amount or percentage your collision insurance goes up after an accident. The total increase depends on many factors, including your driving and claims history, the cost of the claim and state insurance regulations. According to Experian data from February 2026, overall insurance rates rise by an average of $379 after an accident.

How long an accident affects your collision insurance rate varies by insurer, and providers typically don't specify a timeframe for collision coverage alone. Generally, an accident can affect your overall auto insurance rate for an average of three to five years.

By itself, a higher price for your collision coverage won't hurt your credit score. Auto insurance companies typically don't report policy premiums or claims to the major credit reporting agencies. However, if you fail to pay your premiums, your insurer could assign the unpaid debt to a collection agency. The collection account could appear on your credit report and stay there for seven years, starting with the date you first missed that payment.

Your Credit Score Could Affect Your Car Insurance Rates

Your car insurance rates could go up if you've recently filed a claim for an accident or if your driving record shows new moving violations. A higher rate could also be the result of inflation and higher vehicle repair costs. Contact your insurer and ask for specific details on why your rate is higher and what discounts you may qualify for to save money. It's also a good idea to periodically get car insurance quotes from other insurers to make sure you're not overpaying.

Keep in mind, many states allow insurance companies to review your credit-based insurance score when calculating your premium. So before you apply for a new policy, consider checking your credit report and credit scores for free. Review your report and take steps to resolve any issues you find to improve your credit and potentially save money on your car insurance.

Don’t overpay for auto insurance

If you’re looking for ways to cut back on monthly costs, it could be a good idea to see if you can save on your auto insurance.

Find savings
Promo icon.

About the author

Tim Maxwell is a former television news journalist turned personal finance writer and credit card expert with over two decades of media experience. His work has been published in Bankrate, Fox Business, Washington Post, USA Today, The Balance, MarketWatch and others. He is also the founder of the personal finance website Incomist.
Read more from Tim

Explore more topics

Share article

Experian app.

Download the free Experian appCarry trusted financial tools with you

Download from the Apple App Store.Get it on Google Play.
Experian's Diversity logo.

Experian’s Inclusion and BelongingLearn more how Experian is committed