Survey: How Drivers Are Managing Auto Insurance Premium Increases

Quick Answer

Although auto insurance costs have risen by a 22% annual rate, most drivers say they are content with the premium they pay, according to an Experian survey. Only about half of survey respondents have recently shopped for an alternative in the past year.

Saleswoman helping the male customer to choose a new car.

Experian surveyed 1,018 consumers about their auto insurance policies. Survey conducted May 13, 2024. The sample was collected using a third-party company and was not from Experian's consumer credit database.

If you're behind the wheel in 2024, you already know how expensive driving has gotten. Not just because of the monthly payment and the price of gas, but also because of the rising cost to insure your vehicle in the event of an accident.

According to consumer price index (CPI) data, motor vehicle insurance costs represent nearly 3% of a typical consumer's budget. And while premiums were flat during the pandemic, when Americans sharply curtailed their driving, the cost of auto insurance premiums has gone in no direction but up ever since.

Auto Insurance Premium Costs vs. Inflation

But despite the 43% cumulative increase in insurance premiums since 2020, at least some drivers appear unmotivated to lower their costs, according to a May 2024 Experian survey. Let's take a look at what drivers are—and aren't—willing to do to get auto insurance costs under control.

Higher-Income Households More Dissatisfied With Cost of Auto Coverage

It sounds a bit counterintuitive, but drivers who make more money are generally less content with their auto insurance costs, according to our survey. Among drivers with an annual household income above $100,000, 15% say they're dissatisfied with their premiums, versus 9% dissatisfaction among drivers who make less.

Question: How satisfied are you with your current auto insurance premium?

One possible explanation: Those with higher incomes are more likely to drive more expensive vehicles with higher associated repair costs—particularly electric vehicles, which are more popular among households with higher incomes.

Most Drivers Tick Driving Record, Type of Vehicle as Having Greatest Impact on Costs

Overall, most drivers surveyed credited (or blamed) their driving record, the type of vehicle they drive and where they live as having the greatest impact on their auto premiums. The one exception was drivers ages 18 to 24, who cite a major factor besides vehicle type—their age.

They're not wrong. Their lack of driving experience means younger drivers are generally more costly to insure. Vehicle type, model and age all factor into the premium quote you'll receive from an insurer. Also, as credit scores tend to be lower for younger drivers, this may also be a bigger factor for younger drivers in states where credit-based insurance scores are used.

Question: What factors do you believe contribute most to the cost of your auto insurance premium? (Top three responses)

Drivers Who Shop for Lower Auto Insurance Premiums Often Switch

When asked if they have recently compared premium rates across insurers, about half said that they've looked for alternative coverage in the past year, while the other half didn't. Among those who did some price and coverage comparison shopping, however, more than 1 in 3 drivers ended up switching insurers.

Question: Have you changed auto insurance carriers within the past 12 months?

Drivers Mostly OK With Devices That Track Driving for Insurance

Although some drivers are averse to having their driving tracked, most surveyed drivers said they're at least content with having their insurance company monitor their driving, either by their smartphone or with equipment installed in a vehicle's dashboard.

The enthusiasm, or lack thereof, for monitored driving appears to be age-dependent. Older survey respondents indicated they aren't as quick to embrace the newish technology as younger drivers. This may be due to the fact that younger drivers are more incentivized to demonstrate their safe driving habits to lower their premium when they renew coverage. It could also be that younger drivers are more eager or willing to accept technology in their driving lives than older U.S. drivers clinging to more romantic notions of the open road.

Question: Do you use an auto insurance tracking device to monitor your driving? How satisfied are you with the results?

Other Popular Ways to Lower Insurance Premiums

Even if shopping for another insurer or having your driving electronically tracked aren't for you at the moment, there are still other ways to reduce your auto premium costs. The most popular ways to save among drivers we surveyed were:

In most states, improving your credit can be another way to bring down insurance costs. Credit-based insurance scores differ from the scores that lenders use but are based on many of the same factors, including payment history, credit utilization and recent inquiries.

Methodology: The analysis results provided are based on an Experian-created statistically relevant aggregate sampling of our consumer credit database that may include use of the FICO® Score 8 version. Different sampling parameters may generate different findings compared with other similar analysis. Analyzed credit data did not contain personal identification information. Metro areas group counties and cities into specific geographic areas for population censuses and compilations of related statistical data.

FICO® is a registered trademark of Fair Isaac Corporation in the U.S. and other countries.