Credit Lending

With e-commerce booming and more transactions occurring online, the threat of chargeback fraud has never been more significant. In this article, we'll explore chargeback fraud, why it's a growing problem, and, most importantly, how to prevent it. Whether you're a small or large business, understanding and implementing robust chargeback fraud prevention measures is critical to protecting your organization. Understanding chargeback fraud Before we can prevent chargeback fraud, we need to know what we're dealing with. A chargeback happens when a cardholder disputes a transaction, or files a chargeback request, leading to the reversal of the payment to the merchant. Chargebacks can occur for various reasons including: Fraudulent transactions: If a card is stolen or its information is used without authorization, like in the case of account takeover fraud or card not present fraud, the cardholder can dispute the charges. Unauthorized transactions: Even if the cardholder didn't lose their card, they might notice charges they didn't make. Quality issues: If the product or service doesn't meet the cardholder's expectations or has a defect, they might dispute the charge. Billing errors: Sometimes, billing mistakes happen, such as being charged multiple times for the same transaction. Subscription cancellations: When a cardholder cancels a subscription but continues to be billed they can dispute the charges. While there are legitimate reasons for chargebacks, chargeback fraud, also known as friendly fraud, occurs when a customer makes a legitimate purchase with their credit card and then disputes the charge by filing a chargeback request. Unlike third-party fraud, where the cardholder's information is stolen or used without permission, in chargeback fraud, the cardholder initiates the dispute to avoid paying for goods or services they legitimately received. Chargeback fraud can take various forms: False claims of non-receipt: The cardholder claims they never received the purchased item, even though they did. Unauthorized transaction claims: The cardholder denies making the purchase, even though they did so legitimately. Product/service dissatisfaction: The cardholder claims dissatisfaction with the product or service as a reason for disputing the charge, even if the product or service was as described. Subscription services: The cardholder signs up for a subscription service and then disputes the recurring charges as unauthorized or unwanted. Why chargeback fraud is on the rise Chargeback fraud is becoming more pervasive for a couple of reasons. First, as e-commerce grows, so does the opportunity for fraud. Without face-to-face interactions, fraudsters can pull off their schemes more easily. Second, the process of issuing chargebacks has become consumer-friendly, with banks often siding with the cardholder without deep scrutiny of the claim. Finally, with the rise of subscription-based services and digital goods, the incidence of "friendly fraud" is increasing. The impact and repercussions of chargeback fraud The impact of chargeback fraud can be felt across several areas within a business. Financially, it's a clear and direct loss. There are also significant operational costs associated with managing chargebacks, including potential product loss, bank and related fees, and administrative work. However, the less tangible, more insidious repercussions involve damage to the business's reputation. A high chargeback rate can lead to a merchant account being suspended or terminated, causing a loss of the ability to process credit card payments. A tarnished reputation can further lead to losing consumer trust, which can be hard to regain. How to prevent chargeback fraud Preventing and managing chargeback fraud often involves implementing fraud prevention solutions, providing clear communication and customer support, and disputing illegitimate chargebacks with evidence when possible. Here are key actions you can take to protect your business against chargeback fraud: Educate and communicate with customers: Ensure your customers are fully aware of your return and refund policies. Be clear and transparent in your communications about what happens in the event of a disputed transaction. This can significantly reduce misunderstandings that often lead to legitimate chargebacks. Implement stringent transaction verification processes: Utilize Address Verification Services (AVS) and Card Verification Value (CVV2) verification for online and over-the-phone transactions. These credit card authentication services add an extra layer of security and can establish the validity of a purchase. Keep meticulous records: Document all transactions, including emails, phone calls, and any other purchase-related correspondence. In the event of a dispute, these records can serve as compelling evidence to defend the transaction. Immediate shipment and tracking: Ship products as quickly as possible after purchase and provide tracking information to customers. This delights customers and provides tangible proof of delivery should a chargeback be disputed. Utilize advanced fraud detection tools: Many fraud detection services are available that can instantly flag potentially fraudulent transactions, from monitoring for suspicious spending patterns to IP tracking for online orders. Examples include: Tokenization: Tokenization replaces sensitive card data with a "token," a random string of characters that is useless to fraudsters. This token can be stored or transmitted easily, with the actual payment information securely kept off-site. Machine learning and AI: Machine learning and AI fraud detection solutions can analyze vast amounts of transaction data to detect patterns and anomalies, thus flagging potentially fraudulent activity in real-time. The role of customer support in chargeback prevention While the above tools can help your organization prevent fraudulent charge backs, you likely already have a key tool in your company that can help mitigate chargebacks altogether. Your customer support team is your front line in chargeback prevention. Train them to handle customer inquiries effectively and resolve issues before they escalate. Offer multiple contact channels: Give customers several ways to reach your support team, such as email, phone, and live chat. The more easily they can contact you, the less likely they are to resort to a chargeback. Ensure prompt and courteous service: A positive and responsive customer service experience can turn a potential chargeback into a loyalty-building opportunity. Make refunds and returns as easy as possible for your customers. Additionally, clear and generous policies will reduce dissatisfaction and the likelihood of chargebacks. How Experian can help with chargeback fraud prevention Chargeback fraud can be a daunting prospect for any business, but with the right strategies in place, you can protect your business, your customers and your bottom line. Experian’s fraud management solutions provide robust verification options and layered risk management to help reduce the risk of chargeback fraud. Our advanced fraud detection solutions leverage machine learning algorithms and behavioral analytics to confirm the identity of customers during transactions, identify suspicious patterns and activities, and offer deeper insights that enhance fraud prevention strategies. These solutions can help detect potential instances of chargeback fraud in real-time or during post-transaction analysis. Learn More *This article includes content created by an AI language model and is intended to provide general information.

In the dynamic consumer credit landscape, understanding emerging trends is paramount for fintechs to thrive. Experian's latest fintech trends report provides deep insights into the evolving market, shedding light on crucial areas such as origination volumes, average loan balances, and delinquency trends. Let's delve into some key findings and their implications for fintech lenders. Fintech lending origination volume trends The report reveals intriguing shifts in origination volumes for unsecured personal loans and credit cards. While overall origination amounts dipped, fintechs experienced a notable decrease, signaling potential challenges in funding availability and economic uncertainties. Despite this, the total origination volume for fintechs remains robust, underlining their continued significance in the market. Fintech market share versus traditional lenders Fintechs, known for their agility and digital prowess, witnessed fluctuations in market share, particularly in the unsecured personal loan segment. While digital loans continue to drive a significant portion of originations, there's a discernible shift in market dynamics, urging fintech lenders to explore diversification strategies, including expanding into credit card offerings. Fintech lending average loan balance trends Amidst changing economic landscapes, average loan balances for both unsecured personal loans and credit cards exhibited intriguing patterns. Fintech lenders, although maintaining a competitive edge in average balances, face the challenge of balancing risk and profitability, especially amidst rising delinquency levels. Fintech lending delinquency trends One of the most critical aspects highlighted in the report is the uptick in delinquency levels for unsecured personal loans and credit cards. While fintechs navigate through economic uncertainties, there's a growing imperative to enhance risk management strategies and focus on prime and above credit tiers to mitigate potential risks. Understanding the digital borrower As digital borrowing continues to gain prominence, it's essential for fintechs to grasp the nuances of the digital borrower. With millennials emerging as key players in the digital lending landscape, fintechs must tailor their offerings to cater to the unique preferences and behaviors of this demographic segment. Looking ahead to 2024 for fintech lenders As we look to the future, data-driven decision-making and strategic portfolio management are more important than ever for fintechs. With economic uncertainties still in the mix, fintechs must leverage data and analytics to fuel growth while safeguarding against potential risks. Experian's fintech trends report serves as a guiding beacon, equipping fintechs with the knowledge and strategies needed to navigate through uncertainties and unlock opportunities for sustainable growth. The report offers actionable insights, including the imperative to conduct periodic portfolio reviews, retool data analytics and models, and remodel lending criteria to stay ahead in the competitive landscape. Learn more about our fintech solutions and how we can work together to drive profitable growth for your company. Learn more Download the report About the report: Experian's Fintech Trends Report 2024 offers a comprehensive analysis of credit trends, leveraging data from January 2019 to November 2023. The report provides valuable insights into the evolving landscape of unsecured personal loans and credit cards, empowering fintechs with actionable intelligence to thrive in a competitive market environment.

Open banking is revolutionizing the financial services industry by encouraging a shift from a closed model to one with greater transparency, competition, and innovation. But what does this mean for financial institutions, and how can you adapt to this new landscape, balancing opportunity against risk? In this article, we will define open banking, illustrate how it operates, and weigh the challenges and benefits for financial institutions. What is open banking? Open banking stands at the forefront of financial innovation, embodying a shift toward a more inclusive, transparent, and consumer-empowered system. At its core, open banking relies on a simple yet powerful premise: it uses consumer-permissioned data to create a networked banking ecosystem that benefits both financial institutions and consumers alike.  By having secure, standardized access to consumer financial data — granted willingly by the customers themselves — lenders can gain incredibly accurate insights into consumer behavior, enabling them to personalize services and offers like never before. How does open banking work? Open banking is driven by Application Programming Interfaces (APIs), which are sets of protocols that allow different software components to communicate with each other and share data seamlessly and securely. In the context of open banking, these APIs enable: Account Information Services (AIS): These services allow third-party providers (TPPs) to access account information from financial institutions (with customer consent) to provide budgeting and financial planning services. Payment Initiation Services (PIS): These services permit TPPs to initiate payments on behalf of customers, often offering alternative, faster, or cheaper payment solutions compared to traditional banking methods. Financial institutions must develop and maintain robust and secure APIs that TPPs can integrate with. This requires significant investment in technology and cybersecurity to protect customer data and financial assets. There must also be clear customer consent procedures and data-sharing agreements between financial institutions and TPPs. Benefits of open banking Open banking is poised to create a wave of innovation in the financial sector. One of the most significant benefits is the ability to gain a more comprehensive view of a consumer’s financial situation. With a deeper view of consumer cashflow data and access to actionable insights, you can improve your underwriting strategy, optimize account management and make smarter decisions to safely grow your portfolio.  Additionally, open banking promotes financial inclusion by enabling financial institutions to offer more tailored products that suit the needs of previously underserved or unbanked populations. This inclusivity can help bridge the gap in financial services, making them accessible to a broader segment of the population. Furthermore, open banking fosters competition among financial institutions and fintech companies, leading to the development of better products, services, and competitive pricing. This competitive environment not only benefits consumers but also challenges banks to innovate, improve their services, and operate more efficiently. The collaborative nature of open banking encourages an ecosystem where traditional banks and fintech startups co-create innovative open banking solutions. This synergy can accelerate the pace of digital transformation within the banking sector, leading to the development of cutting-edge technologies and platforms that address specific market gaps or consumer demands.  Challenges of open banking While open banking presents a plethora of opportunities, its adoption is not without challenges. Financial institutions must grapple with several hurdles to fully leverage the benefits open banking offers. One of the most significant challenges is fraud detection in banking and ensuring data security and privacy. The sharing of financial data through APIs necessitates robust cybersecurity measures to protect sensitive information from breaches and fraud. Banks and TPPs alike must invest in advanced security technologies and protocols to safeguard customer data. Additionally, regulatory compliance poses a considerable challenge. Open banking regulations vary widely across different jurisdictions, requiring banks to adapt their operations to comply with diverse legal frameworks. Staying abreast of evolving regulations and ensuring compliance can be resource-intensive and complex. Furthermore, customer trust and awareness are crucial to the success of open banking. Many consumers are hesitant to share their financial data due to privacy concerns. Educating customers on the benefits of open banking and the measures taken to ensure their data’s security is essential to overcoming this obstacle. Despite these challenges, the strategic implementation of open banking can unlock remarkable opportunities for innovation, efficiency, and service enhancement in the financial sector. Banks that can successfully navigate these hurdles and capitalize on the advantages of open banking are likely to emerge as leaders in the new era of financial services. Our open banking strategy Our newly introduced open banking solution, Cashflow Attributes, powered by Experian’s proprietary data from millions of U.S. consumers, offers unrivaled categorization and valuable consumer insights. The combination of credit and cashflow data empowers lenders with a deeper understanding of consumers. Furthermore, it harnesses our advanced capabilities to categorize 99% of transaction Demand Deposit Account (DDA) and credit card data, guaranteeing dependable inputs for robust risk assessment, targeted marketing and proactive fraud detection.  Watch open banking webinar Learn more about Cashflow Attributes

In the previous episode of “The Chrisman Commentary” podcast, Joy Mina, Director of Product Commercialization at Experian, talked about the benefits of a waterfall strategy for income and employment verification. In the latest episode, Joy explores common misconceptions around verifications, such as how a lender needs to put a provider with the most records first in their waterfall. "While that might feel like a sure-fire way to cut costs, it isn't necessarily the most effective," said Joy. "Instead of comparing records, I would really encourage lenders to focus on a provider's total cost to verify a consumer." Listen to the full episode to learn about more misconceptions associated with verifications and what you can do to enhance your strategies. Listen to podcast  Learn more

For lenders, first payment default (FPD) is more than just financial jargon; it's a crucial metric in assessing credit risk. This blog post will walk you through the essentials of FPD,  from defining the term to exploring how you can prevent and mitigate its potential impact. Understanding first payment default FPD occurs when a consumer fails to make their initial payment on a loan or credit agreement, which is often perceived as an early signal of a potential cascade of risky behavior. Recognizing FPD is the starting point for lenders to address potential issues with new borrowers before they escalate. One important aspect to grasp is the timeline of FPD. It’s not just about missing the first payment; it's about "early" missing. The timing of defaults is often critical in assessing the overall risk profile of a borrower or group of borrowers. The earlier a borrower starts to miss payments, the riskier they tend to be. Examining the causes of FPD The roots of FPD are diverse and can be classified into two broad categories: External factors: These include sudden financial crises, changes in employment status, or unforeseen expenses. Such factors are often beyond the borrower's immediate control. Internal factors: This category covers more deliberate or chronic financial habits, such as overspending, lack of savings, or overleveraging on credit. It's often indicative of longer-term financial instability. Understanding the causes of early payment default is the first step in effective risk management and customer engagement strategies. Implications of FPD for lenders FPD doesn't just signal immediate financial loss for lenders in terms of the missed installment. It sets off a cascade of consequences that affect the bottom line and the reputation of the institution. Financial loss. Lenders incur direct financial losses when a payment is missed, but the implications go beyond the missed payment amount. There are immediate costs associated with servicing, collections, and customer support. In the longer term, repeated defaults can lead to write-offs, impacting the institution's profitability and regulatory standing. Regulatory scrutiny. Repeated instances of FPD can also draw the attention of regulators, leading to scrutiny and potentially increased compliance costs. Mitigating first payment default Mitigating FPD requires a multifaceted approach that blends data, advanced analytics, customer engagement, and agile risk management. Lenders need to adopt strategies that can detect early signs of potential FPD and intervene preemptively. Data-driven decision-making. Leveraging advanced analytics and credit risk modeling is crucial. By incorporating transactional and behavioral data, lenders can make more accurate assessments of a borrower's risk profile. Utilizing predictive models can help forecast which borrowers are likely to default on their first payment, allowing for early intervention. Proactive customer engagement. Initiatives that revolve around education, personalized financial planning advice, and flexible payment arrangements can help borrowers who might be at risk of FPD. Proactive outreach can engage customers before a default occurs, turning a potential negative event into a positive experience. Agile risk management. Risk management strategies should be dynamic and responsive to changing market and customer conditions. Regularly reviewing and updating underwriting criteria, credit policies, and risk assessment tools ensures that lenders are prepared to tackle FPD challenges as they arise. Using FPD as a customer management tool Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, lenders can use FPD as a tool to foster better customer management. Every FPD is a data point that can provide insights into customer behavior and financial trends. By studying the causes and outcomes of FPD, lenders can refine their risk mitigation tools and improve their customer service offerings. Building trust through handling defaults. How lenders handle defaults, specifically the first ones, can significantly impact customer trust. Transparent communication, fair and considerate policies, and supportive customer service can make a difference in retaining customers and improving the lender's brand image. Leveraging data for personalization. The increasing availability of data means lenders can offer more personalized services. By segmenting customers based on payment behavior and response to early interventions, lenders can tailor offerings that meet the specific financial needs and challenges of individual borrowers. How Experian® can help First payment default is a critical aspect of credit risk management that requires attention and proactive strategies. By understanding the causes, implications, and mitigation strategies associated with FPD, financial institutions can not only avoid potential losses but also build stronger, more enduring relationships with their customers. Learn more about Experian’s credit risk modeling solutions. Learn more This article includes content created by an AI language model and is intended to provide general information.

To say “yes” to consumers faster and more efficiently, financial institutions need flexible access to instant income and employment verification data. In an episode of “The Chrisman Commentary” podcast, Joy Mina, Director of Product Commercialization at Experian, talks about how income and employment verification has changed since Experian entered the market, the benefits of a waterfall strategy, and what’s next in our verifications journey. “Back then, we were hearing lenders primarily asking for more innovative solutions,” said Joy. “They wanted more flexibility without sacrificing quality of service.” Listen to the full episode to learn more about what lenders look for in an income and employment verification solution and how Experian VerifyTM is meeting these needs. Listen to podcast  Learn more

This article was updated on March 12, 2024. The number of decisions that a business must make in the marketing space is on the rise. Which audience to target, what is the best method of communication, which marketing campaign should they receive? To stay ahead, a growing number of businesses are embracing artificial intelligence (AI) analytics, machine learning, and mathematical optimization in their decisioning models and strategies. What is an optimization model? While machine learning models provide predictive insights, it’s the mathematical optimization models that provide actionable insights that drive decisioning. Optimization models factor in multiple constraints and goals to leave you with the next best steps. Each step in the optimization process can significantly improve the overall impact of your marketing outreach — for both you and your customers. Using a mathematical optimization software, you can enhance your targeting, increase response rates, lower cost per acquisition, and drive engagement. Better engagement can lead to stronger business performance and profitability. Here are a few key areas where machine learning and optimization modeling can help increase your return on investment (ROI): Prospecting: Advanced analytics and optimization can be used to better identify individuals who meet your credit criteria and are most likely to respond to your offers. Taking this customer-focused approach, you can provide the most relevant marketing messages to customers at the right time and place. Cross-sell and upsell: The same optimized targeting can be applied to increase profitability with your existing customer base in cross-sell and up-sell opportunities. Gain insights into the best offer to send to each customer, the best time to send it, and which channel the customer will respond best to. Additionally, implement logic that maintains your customer contact protocols. Retention: Employing optimization modeling in the retention stage helps you make quicker decisions in a competitive environment. Instantly identify triggers that warrant a retention offer and determine the likelihood of the customer responding to different offers. LEARN MORE: eBook: Debunking the top 5 myths about optimization Gaining insight and strengthening decisions with our solutions Experian’s suite of advanced analytics solutions, including our optimization software, can help improve your marketing strategies. Use our ROI calculator to get a personalized estimate of how optimization can lift your campaigns without additional marketing spend. Start by inputting your organization’s details below. initIframe('62e81cb25d4dbf17c7dfea55'); Learn more about how optimization modeling can help you achieve your marketing and growth goals. Learn more  

This article was updated on March 11, 2024. As a lender, it’s important to understand a consumer’s credit behavior and whether it's improving or deteriorating over time. Sure, you can pull a credit score at any moment, but it's merely a snapshot. Knowing a consumer’s credit information at a single point in time only tells part of the story. Two consumers can have the same credit score, but one consumer’s score could be moving up while another’s score could be moving down. To understand the whole story, lenders need the ability to leverage trended data to assess a consumer’s credit behavior over time. What to know about trended data Trended data provides key balance and payment data for the previous 24 months. By analyzing historical payment information, lenders can determine if a consumer is consistently paying more than the minimum payment, has a demonstrated ability to pay, and shows no signs of payment stress. It can conversely identify if a consumer is making only minimum payments and has increasing payment stress. Experian’s Trended Data is comprised of five fields of historical payment information over a 24-month period. It includes: Balance Amount Original Loan / Limit Amount Scheduled Payment Amount Actual Payment Amount Last Payment Date Knowing how a consumer uses credit, or pays back debt over time, can help lenders offer the right products and terms to increase response rates, determine up-sell and cross-sell opportunities, and limit loss exposure. Using a consumer’s historical payment information also provides a more accurate assessment of future behavior, helping lenders effectively manage changes in risk, predict balance transfer activity, and prevent attrition. The challenge For lenders to extract the benefits of trended data, they need to analyze an enormous amount of data. Five fields of data across 24 months on every trade is huge and can be difficult for lenders with limited analytical resources to manage. For example, a single consumer with 10 trades on file would have upwards of 1,200 data points to analyze. Multiply that by a file of 100,000 consumers and you are now dealing with over 120,000,000 data points. Additionally, if lenders utilize the trended data in their underwriting processing and intend to use it to decline consumers, they need to create their own adverse action reason codes to communicate to the consumer. Not all lenders are equipped to take on this level of effort. Still, there are trended data solutions to assist lenders with managing and unlocking the power of trended data. How Experian can help Experian’s pre-calculated solutions allow even the smallest lenders to quickly and effectively action on the benefits of trended data, minus the hassles of analyzing it. Trended data, and the solutions built from it, allow lenders to effectively predict where a consumer is going based on where they’ve been. And really, that can make all the difference when it comes to smart lending decisions. Get started today

This article was updated on March 7, 2024. Like so many government agencies, the U.S. military is a source of many acronyms. Okay, maybe a few less, but there really is a host of abbreviations and acronyms attached to the military – and in the regulatory and compliance space, that includes SCRA and MLA. So, what is the difference between the two? And what do financial institutions need to know about them? Let’s break it down in this basic Q&A. SCRA and MLA: Who is covered and when are they covered? The Servicemember Civil Relief Act (SCRA) protects service members and their dependents (indirectly) on existing debts when the service member becomes active duty. In contrast, the Military Lending Act (MLA) protects service members, their spouses and/or covered dependents at point of origination if they are on active duty at that time. For example, if a service member opens an account with a financial institution and then becomes active military, SCRA protections will apply. On the other hand, if the service member is of active duty status when the service member or dependent is extended credit, then MLA protections will apply. Both SCRA and MLA protections cease to apply to a credit transaction when the service member ceases to be on active duty status. What is covered? MLA protections apply to all forms of payday loans, vehicle title loans, refund anticipation loans, deposit advance loans, installment loans, unsecured open-end lines of credit, and credit cards. However, MLA protections exclude loans secured by real estate and purchase-money loans, including a loan to finance the purchase of a vehicle. What are the interest rate limitations for SCRA and MLA? The SCRA caps interest rate charges, including late fees and other transaction fees, at 6 percent. The MLA limits interest rates and fees to 36 percent Military Annual Percentage Rate (MAPR). The MAPR is not just the interest rate on the loan, but also includes additional fees and charges including: Credit insurance premiums/fees Debt cancellation contract fees Debt suspension agreement fees and Fees associated with ancillary products. Although closed-end credit MAPR will be a one-time calculation, open-end credit transactions will need to be calculated for each covered billing cycle to affirm lender compliance with interest rate limitations. Are there any lender disclosure requirements? There is only one set of circumstances that triggers SCRA disclosures. The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires that SCRA disclosures be provided by mortgage servicers on mortgages at 45 days of delinquency. This disclosure must be provided in written format only. For MLA compliance, financial institutions must provide the following disclosures: MAPR statement Payment obligation descriptions Other applicable Regulation Z disclosures. For MLA, it is also important to note that disclosures are required both orally and in a written format the borrower can keep. How Experian can help Experian's solutions help you comply with the Department of Defense's (DOD's) final amendment rule. We can access the DOD's database on your behalf to identify MLA-covered borrowers and provide a safe harbor for creditors ascertaining whether a consumer is covered by the final rule's protection. Visit us online to learn more about our SCRA and military lending act compliance solutions. Learn more

This article was updated on March 6, 2024. Advances in analytics and modeling are making credit risk decisioning more efficient and precise. And while businesses may face challenges in developing and deploying new credit risk models, machine learning (ML) — a type of artificial intelligence (AI) — is paving the way for shorter design cycles and greater performance lifts. LEARN MORE: Get personalized recommendations on optimizing your decisioning strategy Limitations of traditional lending models Traditional lending models have worked well for years, and many financial institutions continue to rely on legacy models and develop new challenger models the old-fashioned way. This approach has benefits, including the ability to rely on existing internal expertise and the explainability of the models. However, there are limitations as well. Slow reaction times:  Building and deploying a traditional credit risk model can take many months. That might be okay during relatively stable economic conditions, but these models may start to underperform if there's a sudden shift in consumer behavior or a world event that impacts people's finances. Fewer data sources:  Traditional scoring models may be able to analyze some types of FCRA-regulated data (also called alternative credit data*), such as utility or rent payments, that appear in credit reports. Custom credit risk scores and models could go a step further by incorporating data from additional sources, such as internal data, even if they're designed in a traditional way. But AI-driven models can analyze vast amounts of information and uncover data points that are more highly predictive of risk. Less effective performance:  Experian has found that applying machine learning models can increase accuracy and effectiveness, allowing lenders to make better decisions. When applied to credit decisioning, lenders see a Gini uplift of 60 to 70 percent compared to a traditional credit risk model.1 Leveraging machine learning-driven models to segment your universe From initial segmentation to sending right-sized offers, detecting fraud and managing collection efforts, organizations are already using machine learning throughout the customer life cycle. In fact, 79% are prioritizing the adoption of advanced analytics with AI and ML capabilities, while 65% believe that AI and ML provide their organization with a competitive advantage.2 While machine learning approaches to modeling aren't new, advances in computer science and computing power are unlocking new possibilities.3 Machine learning models can now quickly incorporate your internal data, alternative data, credit bureau data, credit attributes and other scores to give you a more accurate view of a consumer's creditworthiness. By more precisely scoring applicants, you can shrink the population in the middle of your score range, the segment of medium-risk applicants that are difficult to evaluate. You can then lower your high-end cutoff and raise your low-end cutoff, which may allow you to more confidently swap in  good accounts (the applicants you turned down with other models that would have been good) and swap out bad accounts (those you would have approved who turned bad). Machine learning models may also be able to use additional types of data to score applicants who don't qualify for a score  from traditional models. These applicants aren't necessarily riskier — there simply hasn't been a good way to understand the risk they present. Once you can make an accurate assessment, you can increase your lending universe by including this segment of previously "unscorable" consumers, which can drive revenue growth without additional risk. At the same time, you're helping expand financial inclusion to segments of the population that may otherwise struggle to access credit. READ MORE: Is Financial Inclusion Fueling Business Growth for Lenders? Connecting the model to a decision Even a machine learning model doesn't make decisions.4 The model estimates the creditworthiness of an applicant so lenders can make better-informed decisions. AI-driven credit decisioning software can take your parameters (such cutoff points) and the model's outputs to automatically approve or deny more applicants. Models that can more accurately segment and score populations will result in fewer applications going to manual review, which can save you money and improve your customers' experiences. CASE STUDY:  Atlas Credit, a small-dollar lender, nearly doubled its loan approval rates while decreasing risk losses by up to 20 percent using a machine learning-powered model and increased automation. Concerns around explainability One of the primary concerns lenders have about machine learning models come from so-called “black box" models.5 Although these models may offer large lifts, you can't verify how they work internally. As a result, lenders can't explain why decisions are made to regulators or consumers — effectively making them unusable. While it's a valid concern, there are machine learning models that don't use a black box approach. The machine learning model doesn't build itself and it's not really “learning" on its own — that's where the black box would come in. Instead, developers can use machine learning techniques to create more efficient models that are explainable, don't have a disparate impact on protected classes and can generate reason codes that help consumers understand the outcomes. LEARN MORE: Explainability: Machine learning and artificial intelligence in credit decisioning Building and using machine learning models Organizations may lack the expertise and IT infrastructure required to develop or deploy machine learning models. But similar to how digital transformations in other parts of the business are leading companies to use outside cloud-based solutions, there are options that don't require in-house data scientists and developers. Experian's expert-guided options can help you create, test and use machine learning models and AI-driven automated decisioning; Ascend Intelligence Services™ Acquire:  Our model development service allows you to prebuild and test the performance of a new model before Experian data scientists complete the model. It's collaborative, and you can upload internal data through the web portal and make comments or suggestions. The service periodically retrains your model to increase its effectiveness. Ascend Intelligence Services™ Pulse:  Monitor, validate and challenge your existing models to ensure you're not missing out on potential improvements. The service includes a model health index and alerts, performance summary, automatic validations and stress-testing results. It can also automatically build challenger models and share the estimated lift and financial benefit of deployment. PowerCurve® Originations Essentials:  Cloud-based decision engine software that you can use to make automated decisions that are tailored to your goals and needs. A machine learning approach to credit risk and AI-driven decisioning can help improve outcomes for borrowers and increase financial inclusion while reducing your overall costs. With a trusted and experienced partner, you'll also be able to back up your decisions with customizable and regulatorily-compliant reports. Learn more about our credit decisioning solutions. Learn more When we refer to "Alternative Credit Data," this refers to the use of alternative data and its appropriate use in consumer credit lending decisions as regulated by the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). Hence, the term "Expanded FCRA Data" may also apply in this instance and both can be used interchangeably.1Experian (2024). Improving Your Credit Risk Machine Learning Model Deployment2Experian and Forrester Research (2023). Raising the AI Bar3Experian (2022). Driving Growth During Economic Uncertainty with AI/ML Strategies4Ibid5Experian (2020). Explainability ML and AI in Credit Decisioning

This article was updated on February 28, 2024. There's always a risk that a borrower will miss or completely stop making payments. And when lending is your business, quantifying that credit risk is imperative. However, your credit risk analysts need the right tools and resources to perform at the highest level — which is why understanding the latest developments in credit risk analytics and finding the right partner are important. What is credit risk analytics? Credit risk analytics help turn historical and forecast data into actionable analytical insights, enabling financial institutions to assess risk and make lending and account management decisions. One way organizations do this is by incorporating credit risk modeling into their decisions. Credit risk modeling Financial institutions can use credit risk modeling tools in different ways. They might use one credit risk model, also called a scorecard, to assess credit risk (the likelihood that you won't be repaid) at the time of application. Its output helps you determine whether to approve or deny an application and set the terms of approved accounts. Later in the customer lifecycle, a behavior scorecard might help you understand the risk in your portfolio, adjust credit lines and identify up- or cross-selling opportunities. Risk modeling can also go beyond individual account management to help drive high-level portfolio and strategic decisions. However, managing risk models is an ongoing task. As market conditions and business goals change, monitoring, testing and recalibrating your models is important for accurately assessing credit risk. Credit scoring models Application credit scoring models are one of the most popular applications for credit risk modeling. Designed to predict the probability of default (PD) when making lending decisions, conventional credit risk scoring models focus on the likelihood that a borrower will become 90 days past due (DPD) on a credit obligation in the following 24 months. These risk scores are traditionally logistic regression models built on historical credit bureau data. They often have a 300 to 850 scoring range, and they rank-order consumers so people with higher scores are less likely to go 90 DPD than those with lower scores. However, credit risk models can have different score ranges and be developed to predict different outcomes over varying horizons, such as 60 DPD in the next 12 months. In addition to the conventional credit risk scores, organizations can use in-house and custom credit risk models that incorporate additional data points to better predict PD for their target market. However, they need to have the resources to manage the entire development and deployment or find an experienced partner who can help. The latest trends in credit risk scoring Organizations have used statistical and mathematical tools to measure risk and predict outcomes for decades. But the future of credit underwriting is playing out as big data meets advanced data analytics and increased computing power. Some of the recent trends that we see are: Machine learning credit risk models: Machine learning (ML) is a type of artificial intelligence (AI) that's proven to be especially helpful in evaluating credit risk. ML models can outperform traditional models by 10 to 15 percent.1 Experian survey data from September 2021 found that about 80 percent of businesses are confident in AI and cloud-based credit risk decisioning, and 70 percent frequently discuss using advanced analytics and AI for determining credit risk and collection efforts.2 Expanding data sources: The ML models' performance lift is due, in part, to their ability to incorporate internal and alternative credit data* (or expanded FCRA-regulated data), such as credit data from alternative financial services, rental payments and Buy Now Pay Later loans. Cognitively countering bias: Lenders have a regulatory and moral imperative to remove biases from their lending decisions. They need to beware of how biased training data could influence their credit risk models (ML or otherwise) and monitor the outcomes for unintentionally discriminatory results. This is also why lenders need to be certain that their ML-driven models are fully explainable — there are no black boxes. A focus on agility: The pandemic highlighted the need to have credit risk models and systems that you can quickly adjust to account for unexpected world events and changes in consumer behavior. Real-time analytical insights can increase accuracy during these transitory periods. Financial institutions that can efficiently incorporate the latest developments in credit risk analytics have a lot to gain. For instance, a digital-first lending platform coupled with ML models allows lenders to increasingly automate loan underwriting, which can help them manage rising loan volumes, improve customer satisfaction and free up resources for other growth opportunities. READ: The getting AI-driven decisioning right in financial services white paper to learn more about the current AI decisioning landscape. Why does getting credit risk right matter? Getting credit risk right is at the heart of what lenders do and accurately predicting the likelihood that a borrower won't repay a loan is the starting point. From there, you can look for ways to more accurately score a wider population of consumers, and focus on how to automate and efficiently scale your system. Credit risk analysis also goes beyond simply using the output from a scoring model. Organizations must make lending decisions within the constraints of their internal resources, goals and policies, as well as the external regulatory requirements and market conditions. Analytics and modeling are essential tools, but as credit analysts will tell you, there's also an art to the practice. CASE STUDY: Atlas Credit, a small-dollar lender, worked with Experian's analytics experts to create a custom explainable ML-powered model using various data sources. After reworking the prequalification and credit decisioning processes and optimizing their score cutoffs and business rules, the company can now make instant decisions. It also doubled its approval rate while reducing risk by 15 to 20 percent. How Experian helps clients With decades of experience in credit risk analytics and data management, Experian offers a variety of products and services for financial services firms. Ascend Intelligence Services™ is an award-winning, end-to-end suite of analytics solutions. At a high level, the offering set can rapidly develop new credit risk models, seamlessly deploy them into production and optimize decisioning strategies. It also has the capability to continuously monitor and retrain models to improve performance over time. For organizations that have the experience and resources to develop new credit risk models on their own, Experian can give you access to data and expertise to help guide and improve the process. But there are also off-the-shelf options for organizations that want to quickly benefit from the latest developments in credit risk modeling. Learn more 1Experian (2020). Machine Learning Decisions in Milliseconds 2Experian (2021). Global Insights Report September/October 2021

This article was updated on February 21, 2024. With the rise of technology and data analytics in the financial industry today, it's no longer enough for companies to rely solely on traditional marketing methods. Data-driven marketing insights provide a more sophisticated and comprehensive view of shifting customer preferences and behaviors. With this in mind, this blog post will highlight the importance of data-driven marketing insights, particularly for financial institutions. The importance of data-driven marketing insights 30% of companies say poor data quality is a key challenge to delivering excellent customer experiences. Today’s consumers want personalized experiences built around their individual needs and preferences. Data-driven marketing insights can help marketers meet this demand, but only if it is fresh and accurate. When extending firm credit offers to consumers, lenders must ensure they reach individuals who are both creditworthy and likely to respond. Additionally, their message must be relevant and delivered at the right time and place. Without comprehensive data insights, it can be difficult to gauge whether a consumer is in the market for credit or determine how to best approach them. READ: Case study: Deliver timely and personalized credit offers The benefits of data-driven marketing insights By drawing data-driven marketing insights, you can reach and engage the best customers for your business. This means: Better understanding current and potential customers To increase response and conversion rates, organizations must identify high-propensity consumers and create personalized messaging that resonates. By leveraging customer data that is valid, fresh, and regularly updated, you’ll gain deeper insights into who your customers are, what they’re looking for and how to effectively communicate with them. Additionally, you can analyze the performance of your campaigns and better predict future behaviors. Utilizing technology to manage your customer data With different sources of information, it’s imperative to consolidate and optimize your data to create a single customer view. Using a data-driven technology platform, you can break down data silos by collecting and connecting consumer information across multiple sources and platforms. This way, you can make data available and accessible when and where needed while providing consumers with a cohesive experience across channels and devices. Monitoring the accuracy of your data over time Data is constantly changing, so implementing processes to effectively monitor and control quality over time is crucial. This means leveraging data quality tools that perform regular data cleanses, spot incomplete or duplicated data, and address common data errors. By monitoring the accuracy of your data over time, you can make confident decisions and improve the customer experience. Turning insights into action With data-driven marketing insights, you can level up your campaigns to find the best customers while decreasing time and dollars wasted on unqualified prospects. Visit us to learn more about how data-driven insights can power your marketing initiatives. Learn more Enhance your marketing strategies today This article includes content created by an AI language model and is intended to provide general information.

Developing machine learning (ML) credit risk models can be more challenging than traditional credit risk modeling approaches. But once deployed, ML models can increase automation and expand a lender’s credit universe.  For example, by using ML-driven credit risk models and combining traditional credit data with transactional bank data, a type of alternative credit data* , some lenders see a Gini uplift of 60 to 70 percent compared to a traditional credit risk model.1   New approaches to model operations are also helping lenders accelerate their machine learning model development processes and go from collecting data to deploying a new model in days instead of months.  READ MORE: Getting AI-driven decisioning right in financial services What is machine learning model development? Machine learning model development is what happens before the model gets deployed. It's often broken down into several steps. Define the problem: If you’re building an ML credit risk model, the problem you may be trying to solve is anticipating defaults, improving affordability for borrowers or expanding your lending universe by scoring more thin-file and previously unscorable consumers.  Gather, clean and stage data: Identify helpful data sources, such as internal, credit bureau and alternative credit data. The data will then need to be consolidated, structured, labeled and categorized. Machine learning can be useful here as well, as ML models can be trained to label and categorize raw data. Feature engineering: The data is then analyzed to identify the individual variables and clusters of variables that may offer the most lift. Features that may directly or unintentionally create bias should be removed or limited.  Create the model: Deciding which algorithms and techniques to use when developing a model can be part art and part science. Because lenders need to be able to explain the decisions they make to consumers and regulators, many lenders build model explainability into new ML-driven credit risk models. Validate and deploy: New models are validated and rigorously tested, often as challengers to the existing champion model. If the new model can consistently outperform, it may move on to production.  The work doesn’t stop once a model is live — it needs to be continuously monitored for drift, and potentially recalibrated or replaced with a new model. About 10 percent of lenders use tools to automatically alert them when their models start to drift. But around half make a point of checking deployed models for drift every month or quarter.3  READ MORE: Journey of an ML Model What is model deployment? Model deployment is one of the final steps in the model lifecycle — it’s when you move the model from development and validation to live production.  New models can be deployed in various ways, including via API integration and cloud service deployment using public, private or hybrid architecture. However, integrating a new model with existing systems can be challenging. About a third (33 percent) of consumer lending organizations surveyed in 2023 said it took them one to two months for model deployment-related activities. A little less (29 percent) said it took them three to six months.  Overall, it often takes up to 15 months for the entire development to deployment process — and 55 percent of lenders report building models that never get deployed.2  READ MORE: Accelerating the Model Development and Deployment Lifecycle Benefits of deploying machine learning credit risk models Developing, deploying, monitoring and recalibrating ML models can be difficult and costly. But financial institutions have a lot to gain from embracing the future of underwriting. Improve credit risk assessment: ML-driven models can incorporate more data sources and more precisely assess credit risk to help lenders price credit offers and decrease charge-offs.  Expand automation: More precise scoring can also increase automation by reducing how many applications need to go to manual review.  Increase financial inclusion: ML-models may be able to evaluate consumers who don’t have recent credit information or thick enough credit files to be scorable by traditional models. In short, ML models can help lenders make better loan offers to more people while taking on less risk and using fewer internal resources to review applications.  CASE STUDY: Atlas Credit, a small-dollar lender, partnered with Experian® to develop a fully explainable machine learning credit risk model that incorporated internal data, trended data, alternative financial services data and Experian’s attributes. Atlas Credit can use the new model to make instant decisions and is expected to double its approvals while decreasing losses by up to 20 percent.  How we can help Experian offers many machine learning solutions for different industries and use cases via the Experian Ascend Technology Platform™. For example, with Ascend ML Builder™, lenders can access an on-demand development environment that can increase model velocity — the time it takes to complete a new model’s lifecycle. You can configure Ascend ML Builder based on the compute you allocate and your use cases, and the included code templates (called Accelerators) can help with data wrangling, analysis and modeling.  There’s also Ascend Ops™, a cloud-based model operations solution. You can use Ascend Ops to register, test and deploy custom features and models. Automated model monitoring and management can also help you track feature and model data drift and model performance to improve models in production. Learn more about our machine learning and model deployment solutions *When we refer to “Alternative Credit Data,” this refers to the use of alternative data and its appropriate use in consumer credit lending decisions, as regulated by the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Hence, the term “Expanded FCRA Data” may also apply and can be used interchangeably. 1. Experian (2023). Raising the AI Bar 2. Experian (2023). Accelerating Model Velocity in Financial Institutions 3. Ibid.

As a community bank or credit union, your goal is to provide personalized care and attention to your customers and members while effectively managing regulatory requirements and operational efficiency. By incorporating tools such as income and employment verification, you can streamline the approval process for both account holders and prospects. With the ability to validate their information in seconds, you'll be able to make well-informed decisions faster and accelerate conversion. In this blog post, we will explore the empowering impact of income and employment verification on financial institutions. Better Data, Better Decisions Choosing a verification partner with an instant employer payroll network allows financial institutions to access reliable and up-to-date income and employment information for confident decision-making. With accurate and timely data at their fingertips, you can gain a deeper understanding of your account holders’ capacity to pay, a critical component to assessing overall financial health. This not only helps mitigate risk but also helps you serve your customers and members more effectively. There are additional benefits to partnering with a verification solution provider that is also a Credit Reporting Agency (CRA) offering FCRA-compliant technologies. These organizations are well versed in compliance matters and can help you more effectively mitigate risk. Streamline Approval Times and Remove Friction When developing your verification process, it is advantageous to adopt a waterfall or multi-step approach that encompasses instant verification, permissioned verification, and, as a last resort, manual verification. This tiered approach will significantly reduce approval times, manage costs effectively, and streamline the approval process. Instant verification relies on advanced technology to provide swift and efficient results. In cases where instant verification is unavailable, the process seamlessly transitions to permissioned verification, where explicit consent is obtained from individuals to access their payroll data directly from their respective providers. Lastly, manual verification involves collecting payroll and employment documents, which is a more time-consuming and costly process. By implementing this comprehensive approach, you can enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of your verification process while maintaining the integrity of the results. A Flexible Solution Community banks and credit unions are integral to the lending industry. It is crucial for them to select a versatile verification solution that can keep pace with the approval speed of both regional and large banks. Given that community banks and credit unions operate in smaller geographic regions compared to larger institutions, it is imperative for them to have a verification solution that is versatile and can be applied across their entire spectrum of loan offerings, including mortgage loans, automotive loans, credit cards, home equity loans, and consumer loans. This adaptability enables community banks and credit unions to consistently serve their account holders and enhances their ability to compete effectively with larger financial institutions. With a robust verification solution in place, community banks and credit unions can confidently navigate the complexities of the lending landscape and deliver exceptional results for their valued account holders. World-Class Service and Support To ensure a seamless verification journey, community banks and credit unions should choose a solution provider that delivers exceptional service and support. From the initial onboarding process and comprehensive training to ongoing troubleshooting and guidance, a dedicated and knowledgeable support team becomes indispensable in establishing a successful verification process. Having hands-on training and support not only instills peace of mind but also empowers community-focused financial institutions to consistently provide a high level of personalized service, fostering trust and loyalty among their customers and members. By investing in a robust support system, community banks and credit unions can confidently navigate the verification landscape and stay ahead in an ever-evolving financial industry, reinforcing their commitment to delivering an outstanding experience to their communities. As a longstanding leader in the financial industry, Experian understands the unique challenges faced by community banks and credit unions. Our verification solution, Experian VerifyTM, provides accurate, efficient, and compliant income and employment verification services. With Experian Verify, community focused financial institutions can navigate the complexities of income and employment verification with ease, achieving new levels of efficiency and success. To learn more about how Experian Verify can benefit your bank or credit union, we invite you to visit our website and schedule a personalized demo. Together, let's unlock the potential of income and employment verification and elevate your financial institution to new heights of success. Learn more

This article was updated on February 13, 2024. Traditional credit data has long been a reliable source for measuring consumers' creditworthiness. While that's not changing, new types of alternative credit data are giving lenders a more complete picture of consumers' financial health. With supplemental data, lenders can better serve a wider variety of consumers and increase financial access and opportunities in their communities. What is alternative credit data? Alternative credit data, also known as expanded FCRA-regulated data, is data that can help you evaluate creditworthiness but isn't included in traditional credit reports.1 To comply with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), alternative credit data must be displayable, disputable and correctable. Lenders are increasingly turning to new types and sources of data as the use of alternative credit data becomes the norm in underwriting. Today, lenders commonly use one or more of the following: Alternative financial services data: Alternative financial services (AFS) credit data can include information on consumers' use of small-dollar installment loans, single-payment loans, point-of-sale financing, auto title loans and rent-to-own agreements. Consumer permission data: With a consumer's permission, you can get transactional and account-level data from financial accounts to better assess income, assets and cash flow. The access can also give insight into payment history on non-traditional accounts, such as utilities, cell phone and streaming services. Rental payment history: Property managers, electronic rent payment services and rent collection companies can share information on consumers' rent payment history and lease terms. Full-file public records: Local- and state-level public records can tell you about a consumer's professional and occupational licenses, education, property deeds and address history. Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) data: BNPL tradeline and account data can show you payment and return histories, along with upcoming scheduled payments. It may become even more important as consumers increasingly use this new type of point-of-sale financing. By gathering more information, you can get a deeper understanding of consumers' creditworthiness and expand your lending universe. From market segmentation to fraud prevention and collections, you can also use alternative credit data throughout the customer lifecycle. READ: 2023 State of Alternative Credit Data Report Challenges in underwriting today While unemployment rates are down, high inflation, rising interest rates and uncertainty about the economy are impacting consumer sentiment and the lending environment.2 Additionally, lenders may need to shift their underwriting approaches as pandemic-related assistance programs and loan accommodations end. Lenders may want to tighten their credit criteria. But, at the same time, consumers are becoming accustomed to streamlined application processes and responses. A slow manual review could lead to losing customers. Alternative credit data can help you more accurately assess consumers' creditworthiness, which may make it easier to identify high-risk applicants and find the hidden gems within medium-risk segments. Layering traditional and alternative credit data with the latest approaches to model building, such as using artificial intelligence, can also help you implement precise and predictive underwriting strategies. Benefits of using alternative data for credit underwriting Using alternative data for credit underwriting — along with custom credit attributes and automation — is the modern approach to a risk-based credit approval strategy. The result can offer: A greater view of consumer creditworthiness: Personal cash flow data and a consumer's history of making (or missing) payments that don't appear on traditional credit reports can give you a better understanding of their financial position. Improve speed and accuracy of credit decisions: The expanded view helps you create a more efficient underwriting process. Automated underwriting tools can incorporate alternative credit data and attributes with meaningful results. One lender, Atlas Credit, worked with Experian to create a custom model that incorporated alternative credit data and nearly doubled its approvals while reducing risk by 15 to 20 percent.3 Increase financial inclusion: There are 28 million American adults who don't have a mainstream credit file and 21 million who aren't scoreable by conventional scoring models.4 With alternative credit data, you may be able to more accurately assess the creditworthiness of adults who would otherwise be deemed thin file or unscorable. Broadening your pool of applications while appropriately managing risk is a measurable success. What Experian builds and offers Experian is continually expanding access to expanded FCRA-regulated data. Our Experian RentBureau and Clarity Services (the leading source of alternative financial credit data) have long given lenders a more complete picture of consumers' financial situation. Experian also helps lenders effectively use these new types of data. You can also incorporate the data into your proprietary marketing, lending and collections strategies. Experian is also using alternative credit data for credit scoring. The Lift Premium™ model can score 96 percent of U.S. adults — compared to the 81 percent that conventional models can score using traditional data.5 The bottom line Lenders have been testing and using alternative credit data for years, but its use in underwriting may become even more important as they need to respond to changing consumer expectations and economic uncertainty. Experian is supporting this innovation by expanding access to alternative data sources and helping lenders understand how to best use and implement alternative credit data in their lending strategies. Learn more 1When we refer to “Alternative Credit Data," this refers to the use of alternative data and its appropriate use in consumer credit lending decisions, as regulated by the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Hence, the term “Expanded FCRA Data" may also apply and can be used interchangeably. 2Experian (2024). State of the Economy Report 3Experian (2020). OneAZ Credit Union [Case Study] 4Oliver Wyman (2022). Financial Inclusion and Access to Credit [White Paper] 5Ibid.