Loading...

Navigating the Risk of Doing Business with Unsecured Third Parties

Published: February 5, 2024 by Michael Bruemmer

Insights from the Cyber Risk Summit Beverly Hills – October 2023

Authored by Ryan Coyne

I recently participated in a panel with industry experts, delving into third-party cyber risks. The panel shed light on best practices, challenges, and strategies to mitigate the impact of third-party incidents.

Panel Participants:

  • Stu Panensky (Moderator) – FisherBroyles, LLP
  • Ryan Coyne – Experian
  • Tom Egglestone – Resilience
  • Mark Grazman – Fenix24
  • Matthew Saidel – FTI Consulting

Agenda:

  1. Incident Best Practices: Collaboration & Coordination on IR Action Items
  2. Upstream Risk of Third Parties: Vendors, Suppliers & Business Partners
  3. Downstream Risk in the Policyholder Supply Chain

The Cyber Risk Summit held in Beverly Hills provided valuable insights into the risks of engaging unsecured third parties.

Key Takeaways

Understanding the Significance

Tom emphasized the longstanding nature of cyber risk exposure tied to third-party relationships. The increasing reliance on external vendors in a tech-enabled world has heightened this risk, especially with the surge in outsourcing and software adoption. Tom highlighted that, even in 2019, Gartner research indicated that 60% of surveyed companies worked with over 1000 third parties in their supply chain, setting the stage for the escalated risk environment post-pandemic.

Crisis Communications in Third-Party Incidents

Matt shared insights into the challenges faced when third-party incidents unfold. The necessity of involving crisis communications consultants early in the process, especially for upstream and downstream, was stressed. Preserving the right to operate and maintaining client trust amid incidents were key points Matt made.
Hands-On Restoration Perspective
Mark, providing a hands-on restoration perspective, discussed the rarity of involvement at the inception of an event. His emphasis on locking down infrastructure, understanding the threat actor’s persistency, and encouraging robust backup strategies showcased the intricacies involved in restoration efforts.
“Restoration efforts often kick in when patient zero is unidentified. Locking down the infrastructure and focusing on repairing affected elements are essential” – Mark Grazman, Fenix24

Notification Strategies and Legal Implications

Representing Experian, I shared my perspective on notification complexities that the average consumer may not be aware of, such as notifying everyone upfront versus opt-in processes. The legal implications of notifying on behalf of others and coordinating with multiple parties. The nuanced approach to call center communication and the crucial factor of making details clear in notification letters in minimizing confusion for recipients.
I want to emphasize a point I made earlier in the panel on the downstream impact of notification strategies and the need to customize communication for recipients.
“For these incidents, it’s most important to minimize complexity on the notification side and minimize confusion for the recipient of your notification letter.” – Ryan Coyne, Experian

Insights from an Insurance Claims Handler

Tom, as an insurance claims handler, underscored the importance of understanding vendor contracts, particularly clauses related to defense and indemnity. He highlighted the need for transparency in the vendor’s incident response process, especially when the insured isn’t in control, adding a layer of complexity to communication and expectation setting.

Crafting a Seamless Notification Process: Public-Private Partnerships

Stu Panensky, Moderator: Public-private partnerships emerged as a recurring theme during the panel discussions. The need for collaboration between law enforcement, insurance companies, and businesses became evident. Stu emphasized the role of public-private partnerships in influencing better outcomes and impacting data protection, regulation, and litigation.

The insights from the 2023 Beverly Hills Cyber Risk Summit underline the interconnected nature of cyber risks and the critical importance of proactive measures. Stakeholders are urged to adopt a collaborative approach, navigate legal complexities, and stay vigilant in the face of evolving challenges. I welcome you to watch the full discussion on-demand.

Related Posts

Data breaches continue to be a reality for organizations across industries, and the complexity of responding to them is only increasing. From AI-driven fraud to third-party exposures, the risk landscape is shifting fast. Having a modern and tested response plan is essential to containing the damage, protecting your customers, and preserving your organization’s reputation when a breach occurs. Experian’s eleventh annual Data Breach Response Guide draws on decades of breach support experience. It offers practical strategies and insights for navigating the moments that matter most: the first hours after a breach and the days that follow. The 2025–2026 guide explores: How AI is shaping new breach and fraud patterns Where organizations are most vulnerable, including third-party and supply chain weak points Consumer expectations and how they influence crisis response How prepared organizations are reducing impact and protecting trust What is required to build a modern, effective breach response plan Organizations with a tested plan can potentially reduce the cost, impact, and long-term consequences of a breach. From real-world case insights to crisis communication templates, this guide is designed to help teams act quickly and confidently. Download the 2025–2026 Data Breach Response Guide to learn how you can strengthen your breach preparedness, reduce risk exposure, and build resilience against the next wave of cybersecurity threats. Download guide

Published: August 4, 2025 by Julie Lee

As data breaches become an ever-growing threat to businesses, the role of employees in maintaining cybersecurity has never been more critical. Did you know that 82% of data breaches involve the human element1 , such as phishing, stolen credentials, or social engineering tactics? These statistics reveal a direct connection between employee identity theft and business vulnerabilities. In this blog, we’ll explore why protecting your employees’ identities is essential to reducing data breach risk, how employee-focused identity protection programs, and specifically employee identity protection, improve both cybersecurity and employee engagement, and how businesses can implement comprehensive solutions to safeguard sensitive data and enhance overall workforce well-being. The Rising Challenge: Data Breaches and Employee Identity Theft The past few years have seen an exponential rise in data breaches. According to the Identity Theft Resource Center, there were 1,571 data compromises in the first half of 2024, impacting more than 1.1 billion individuals – a 490% increase year over year2. A staggering proportion of these breaches originated from compromised employee credentials or phishing attacks. Explore Experian's Employee Benefits Solutions The Link Between Employee Identity Theft and Cybersecurity Risks Phishing and Social EngineeringPhishing attacks remain one of the top strategies used by cybercriminals. These attacks often target employees by exploiting personal information stolen through identity theft. For example, a cybercriminal who gains access to an employee's compromised email or social accounts can use this information to craft realistic phishing messages, tricking them into divulging sensitive company credentials. Compromised Credentials as Entry PointsCompromised employee credentials were responsible for 16% of breaches and were the costliest attack vector, averaging $4.5 million per breach3. When an employee’s identity is stolen, it can give hackers a direct line to your company’s network, jeopardizing sensitive data and infrastructure. The Cost of DowntimeBeyond the financial impact, data breaches disrupt operations, erode customer trust, and harm your brand. For businesses, the average downtime from a breach can last several weeks – time that could otherwise be spent growing revenue and serving clients. Why Businesses Need to Prioritize Employee Identity Protection Protecting employee identities isn’t just a personal benefit – it’s a strategic business decision. Here are three reasons why identity protection for employees is essential to your cybersecurity strategy: 1. Mitigate Human Risk in Cybersecurity Employee mistakes, often resulting from phishing scams or misuse of credentials, are a leading cause of breaches. By equipping employees with identity protection services, businesses can significantly reduce the likelihood of stolen information being exploited by fraudsters and cybercriminals. 2. Boost Employee Engagement and Financial Wellness Providing identity protection as part of an employee benefits package signals that you value your workforce’s security and well-being. Beyond cybersecurity, offering such protections can enhance employee loyalty, reduce stress, and improve productivity. Employers who pair identity protection with financial wellness tools can empower employees to monitor their credit, secure their finances, and protect against fraud, all of which contribute to a more engaged workforce. 3. Enhance Your Brand Reputation A company’s cybersecurity practices are increasingly scrutinized by customers, stakeholders, and regulators. When you demonstrate that you prioritize not just protecting your business, but also safeguarding your employees’ identities, you position your brand as a leader in security and trustworthiness. Practical Strategies to Protect Employee Identities and Reduce Data Breach Risk How can businesses take actionable steps to mitigate risks and protect their employees? Here are some best practices: Offer Comprehensive Identity Protection Solutions A robust identity protection program should include: Real-time monitoring for identity theft Alerts for suspicious activity on personal accounts Data and device protection to protect personal information and devices from identity theft, hacking and other online threats Fraud resolution services for affected employees Credit monitoring and financial wellness tools Leading providers like Experian offer customizable employee benefits packages that provide proactive identity protection, empowering employees to detect and resolve potential risks before they escalate. Invest in Employee Education and Training Cybersecurity is only as strong as your least-informed employee. Provide regular training sessions and provide resources to help employees recognize phishing scams, understand the importance of password hygiene, and learn how to avoid oversharing personal data online. Implement Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) MFA adds an extra layer of security, requiring employees to verify their identity using multiple credentials before accessing sensitive systems. This can drastically reduce the risk of compromised credentials being misused. Partner with a Trusted Identity Protection Provider Experian’s suite of employee benefits solutions combines identity protection with financial wellness tools, helping your employees stay secure while also boosting their financial confidence. Only Experian can offer these integrated solutions with unparalleled expertise in both identity protection and credit monitoring. Conclusion: Identity Protection is the Cornerstone of Cybersecurity The rising tide of data breaches means that businesses can no longer afford to overlook the role of employee identity in cybersecurity. By prioritizing identity protection for employees, organizations can reduce the risk of costly breaches and also create a safer, more engaged, and financially secure workforce. Ready to protect your employees and your business? Take the next step toward safeguarding your company’s future. Learn more about Experian’s employee benefits solutions to see how identity protection and financial wellness tools can transform your workplace security and employee engagement. Learn more 1 2024 Experian Data Breach Response Guide 2 Identity Theft Resource Center. H1 2024 Data Breach Analysis 3 2023 IBM Cost of a Data Breach Report

Published: January 28, 2025 by Stefani Wendel

  With cyber threats intensifying and data breaches rising, understanding how to respond to incidents is more important than ever. In this interview, Michael Bruemmer, Head of Global Data Breach Resolution at Experian, is joined by Matthew Meade, Chair of the Cybersecurity, Data Protection & Privacy Group at Eckert Seamans, to discuss the realities of data breach response. Their session, “Cyber Incident Response: A View from the Trenches,” brings insights from the field and offers a preview of Experian's 2025 Data Breach Industry Forecast, including the role of generative artificial intelligence (AI) in data breaches. From the surge in business email compromises (BEC) to the relentless threat of ransomware, Bruemmer and Meade dive into key issues facing organizations big and small today. Drawing from Experian's experience handling nearly 5,000 breaches this year, Bruemmer sheds light on effective response practices and reveals common pitfalls. Meade, who served as editor-in-chief for the Sedona Conference’s new Model Data Breach Notification Law, explains the implications of these regulatory updates for organizations and highlights how standardized notification practices can improve outcomes. Bruemmer and Meade’s insights offer a proactive guide to tackling tomorrow’s cyber threats, making it a must-listen for anyone aiming to stay one step ahead. Listen to the full interview for a valuable look at both the current landscape and what's next.  Click here for more insight into safeguarding your organization from emerging cyber threats.  

Published: November 20, 2024 by Julie Lee