Vendor auditing best practices that will help your organization succeed

Updated: June 12, 2026 by Guest Contributor 5 min read March 29, 2012

Jeff Bernstein Experian Global Consulting Practice Risk Management

Auditing provides the organization with assurance that all financial controls are in place to ensure that trust account funds are maintained, access to financial records at the vendor location is tightly controlled, customer data is secure, and that the vendor is in full compliance with contractual requirements (i.e., minimum account servicing requirements for issues such as vendor actions following initial placement, ongoing contact efforts, remittance processing, settlement authorizations, etc.).

There are two basic auditing processes that occur from a best practices perspective. The first one is fairly common, and involves use of an on-site audit.

Onsite Auditing

The onsite audit is required to examine financial records involving customer transactions, accounting processes, trust accounts and remittances, IT and security for handling sensitive customer information and records, and documentation of the processes that have occurred towards customer communication, contact efforts and results.

There are differences of opinion as to both the frequency of onsite audits, and whether they should be announced or unannounced. Frequency is primarily an issue of the size of the overall vendor relationship and the degree of financial risk associated with a default, typically involving the trust account and legal exposure to litigation and brand reputation risk.

Most utilities should follow an annual onsite audit schedule due to size of portfolio and attendant financial exposure. While surprise audits have the advantage of reducing any opportunity by the vendor to potentially alter records to cover up what would normally be audit violations, it does result in a more time-consuming audit schedule onsite, as the vendor is unable to prepare and have documentation available. The use of substantial online documentation lessens this issue, but nonetheless, there is more work to do onsite when nothing has been captured for review in advance. The other issue is that key managers from the vendor may not be available on the dates of a surprise audit.

One way in which organizations chose to resolve the issue of surprise versus planned audit is to conduct one pre-planned and announced audit annually, and a smaller scaled unannounced onsite audit annually at least 2 quarters separated from the planned audit. The use of remote auditing and monitoring lessens the requirements for onsite audits in certain areas, other than IT / Security, financial and compliance.

Remote Auditing / Monitoring

Remote auditing and monitoring of vendors is a stronger tool for credit grantors to improve performance of agencies, in that it combines some of the same auditing checks to ensure compliance and quality of collections with an added value of focus on performance.

The best tool in the arsenal is the use of digital logging to capture the collection call between the vendor and customers. When digital logging technology first came into use, it was cost prohibitive for collection agencies, and not fully accepted by the industry due to its possible use in litigation against the agencies. Over the past decade, as the costs of deployment have lessened, and agencies became more attuned to customer satisfaction and full FDCPA compliance, more agencies have installed digital logging into their call centers.

Most agencies that utilize digital logging capture every customer contact effort that results in either a right party contact, or third party contact for messages, etc. Many of those agencies will tag each of these voice records as to whether they were a right party contact or not. The intent is to be able to audit more frequently those calls that were right party contacts, so that collector skills can be assessed in terms of how they managed the customer, their ability to create and sell payment solution, and ability to negotiate successfully with the customer.

Typically, an organization that is using digital logging will have an internal quality assurance team that will create a compliance audit process that establishes a number of right party and non-right party contacts per collector. These calls are typically evaluated using a scorecard approach, and used for training purposes. They might alter the frequencies of monitoring based upon the tenure of the collector, their performance levels, and the results of prior monitoring, such that sample sizes are affected.

Utilities and other credit grantors should have access to the entire inventory of raw digital log files for their projects and randomly audit them remotely. These should not be “assembled” or pre-selected by the vendor, so that there is no undue influence in deciding which calls / collectors to review. If the vendor is using a QA monitoring / compliance program and separately maintains a scorecard driven monitoring process, the credit grantor should have access where those calls and evaluations related to their own customers and contacts.

The intent of the process is to listen for both quality of the communication with the customer from the perspective of effectiveness, but also to ensure compliance with FDCPA and that the customer was treated with respect and appropriately. Typically, a credit grantor would establish a remote monitoring schedule where x calls across the agent pool handing their assigned portfolio are monitored and evaluated with a simple checklist. Ideally, the credit grantor should be listening to a range of 100-150 right party contacts per month, based upon overall inventory and activity, but typically no more than 1-2% of the total right party contacts per month on their customer accounts.

The credit grantor should provide monthly feedback to the agency regarding the monitoring of quality and compliance, noting any compliance or policy violations, and any concerns relating to customer contact quality and performance.

Other aspects of the remote auditing that occurs each month should include ensuring that all servicing requirements are met. As an example, we would expect that the agency should perform various external checks for bankruptcy, deceased, etc. before initiating contact once the file has been received from the credit grantor as a placement. These database checks should be performed within the first 24 hours once placed, and then a letter of representation should be sent to those not flagged. The initial call to the customer should also occur within 24-48 hours from placement by the credit grantor, subject to phone number availability. Skip trace processes should commence immediately on those without phone numbers. There are requirements for how often accounts are attempted for contact, and settlement authorizations. All of these requirements are subject to the remote monitoring that is performed to ensure these are met.

Coming soon... Best practices for improving agency performance.

Related Posts

How GenAI Fraud Bots Fly Under the Radar (and How to Ground Them Before It’s Too Late)

Today’s AI-powered fraud bots are exceptionally good at mimicking human behavior. Learn why a modern defense strategy is key.

November 18, 2026 by Laura Burrows
What Is Incident Response? Key Steps, Planning and Best Practices

Learn what incident response is, the key steps in the process and how to build and test an incident response plan for a data breach.

November 17, 2026 by Laura Burrows
Rethinking Charged-Off Portfolio Prioritization

Experian’s new Recovery Scores model turns portfolio intelligence into more focused recovery strategies, helping organizations improve returns, direct effort and accelerate speed to cash. The challenge isn’t simply working more accounts. Whether a debt buyer is evaluating an acquisition, an agency is deciding where to assign collector time or a lender is managing its own post-charge-off accounts, the question is similar: How can limited capacity be directed toward accounts with the greatest potential for recovery? Prioritizing accounts mainly by age, balance or when they were last worked may not show which ones are most likely to generate a recovery. With the new Recovery Scores model, organizations can rank charged-off accounts by expected collectability, providing a consistent signal to inform placement strategy and treatment decisions across the recovery lifecycle. Make collector capacity a strategic resource Working every account with the same level of attention isn’t always practical. The more useful question is: Where should teams focus first to protect speed to cash? Our model performance analysis found: 80% of recovered dollars come from the top 40% of accounts worked. The value isn’t simply a better ranking. It’s how organizations can use it for collections optimization. Score bands can inform different strategies for placement, outsourcing, auction and legal channel treatment rather than applying the same approach across an entire portfolio. For debt buyers: The scores can inform acquisition pricing and how a newly purchased portfolio is divided across internal collections, legal channels and resale. Expected collectability can shape debt portfolio analysis, including how a portfolio is valued and segmented before collection work begins. For agencies: Score bands can help teams focus collector resources on accounts with stronger recovery potential. For first-party lenders: Managing recovery internally, the scores provide another signal to help structure decisions about which accounts to work and in what order. Look beyond collectability alone Prioritization rarely comes down to a single variable. Consider two accounts that both rank highly for expected collectability, but one has a substantially larger balance. Their recovery likelihood may be similar, but the potential dollars recovered are not. The Recovery Scores model uses debt collections analytics by combining Experian’s bureau-based score with current balance information. This helps organizations consider both the likelihood of recovery and the potential dollars at stake, while sensitive balance information remains within the organization’s working environment. Monitor accounts as they change The first decision about an account is rarely the last. Teams continually make choices about treatment, placement and resource allocation as accounts move through the recovery process. Recovery Scores is also available as a trigger. When underlying information changes, teams can receive an update and reconsider an account’s placement without waiting for the next portfolio-wide re-score. An account that shows lower recovery potential today may have a different recovery outlook later. Turn recovery potential into a portfolio strategy When portfolios contain more accounts than teams can work at once, the question isn’t simply, “How many accounts can we work?” It is, “Where can our resources have the greatest impact?” The latest Recovery Scores model helps organizations sharpen placement and treatment decisions. It gives debt buyers a way to price and segment portfolios with greater confidence and gives lenders another tool to direct limited collector time across their own post-charge-off portfolios. Learn more about Experian Recovery Scores

November 10, 2026 by Zohreen Ismail

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Enter your name and email for the latest updates.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Don't miss out on the latest industry trends and insights!
Subscribe