Small Business Market Segmentation Strategies

by Guest Contributor 7 min read November 28, 2011

By: Joel Pruis

Basic segmentation strategy for business banking asks the following questions:

– Is there a uniform definition of small business across the industry?
– How should small business be defined?  Sales size of the applicant?  Exposure to the financial institution?
– Is small business/business banking a retail or commercial line of business?

No One Size Fits All

The notion of a single definition for small business for any financial institution is inappropriate as the intent for segmentation is to focus marketing efforts, establish appropriate products to support the segment, develop appropriate delivery methods and use appropriate risk management practices.  For the purpose of this discussion we will restrict our content to developing the definition of the segment and high level credit product terms and conditions to support the segment.

The confusion on how to define the segment is typically due to the multiple sources of such definitions.  The Small Business Administration, developers of generic credit risk scorecards (such as Experian), marketing firms and the like all have multiple ways to define small business.  While they all have a different method of defining small business, the important factor to consider is that each definition serves the purpose of the creator.  As such, the definition of small business should serve the purpose of the specific financial institution.

A general rule of thumb is the tried and true 80/20 rule.  Assess your financial institution’s business purpose portfolio by rank ordering individual relationships by total dollar exposure.  Using the 80/20 rule, determine the smallest 80% of the number of relationships by exposure.  Typically the result is that the largest 20% of relationships will cover approximately 80% of the total dollars outstanding in your business purpose portfolio.  Conversely the smallest 80% of relationships will cover only about 20% of the total dollars outstanding.

Just from this basic analysis we can see the primary need for segmentation between the business banking and the commercial (middle market, commercial real estate, etc.) portfolios.  Assuming we do not segment we have a significant imbalance of effort vs. actual risk.  Meaning if we treat all credit relationships the same we are spending up to 80% of our time/resources on only 20% of our dollar risk.  Looking at this from the other direction we are only spending 20% of our credit resources assessing 80% of our total dollar risk.  Obviously this is a very basic analysis but any way that you look at it, the risk assessment (underwriting and portfolio management) must be “right-sized” in order to provide the appropriate risk management while working to maximize the return on such portfolio segments.

The realities of the credit risk assessment practices without segmentation is that the small business segment will be managed by exception, at best.  Given the large number of relationships and the small impact that the small business segment has on traditional credit quality metrics such as past dues and charge offs, the performance of the small business portfolio can, in fact, be hidden.  Such metrics focus on percentage of dollars that are past due or charged off against the entire portfolio.  Since the largest dollars are in the 20% of relationships, it will take a significant number of individual small business relationships being delinquent or charged off before the overall metric would become alarming.

Working with our clients in defining small business, one of the first exercises that we recommend is assessing the actual delinquency and charge off rates in the newly defined small business/business banking portfolio.  Simply put, determine the total dollars that fit the new definition and apply the charge-offs by borrowers that meet the definition that have occurred over the past 12 months divided by total outstanding in the new portfolio segment.  Similarly determine the current dollars past due of relationships meeting the definition of small business divided by the total outstanding of said segment.  Such results typically are quite revealing and will at least provide a baseline for which the financial institution can measure improvement and/or success.  Without such initial analysis, we have witnessed financial institutions laying blame on the new underwriting and portfolio management processes for such performance when it existed all along but was never measured.

So basically our first attempt to define the segment has created a total credit exposure limit.  Such limits should be used to determine the appropriate underwriting and portfolio management methods (both of which we will discuss further subsequent blogs), but this type of a definition does little to support a business development effort as the typical small business does not always borrow nor can we accurately assess the potential dollar exposure of any given business until we actually gather additional data.  Thus for business development purposes we establish the definition of small business primarily by sales size.  Looking at the data from your existing relationships, your financial institution can get an accurate indication of the maximum sales size that should be considered in the business development efforts.

As a result we have our business development definition by sales size of a given company and our underwriting and portfolio management defined by total exposure.  You may be thinking that such definitions are not always in sync with each other and you would be correct.  You will have some companies with total sales under your definition that borrower more than your total exposure limits while companies with total exposure that falls under small business but the total sales of such companies may exceed the business development limit.  It is impossible to catch every possibility and to do so is an exercise in futility.  Better that you start with the basics of the segmentation and then measure the new applications that exceed the total exposure or the relationships meeting the total exposure cap but exceed the sales limitation.  During the initial phase, judgment on a case by case basis will need to be used.

Questions such as:

  • Is the borrower that exceeds our sales limitations likely to need to borrow more in the near future?
  • Is the exposure of the borrower that meets our sales size requirement likely to quickly reduce its exposure to meet our definition?
  • Will our underwriting techniques be adequate to assess the risk of this relationship?
  • Will our portfolio monitoring methods be sufficient to assess the changes in the risk profile after it has been booked?
  • Will the relationship management structure be sufficient to support such a borrower?

As you encounter these situations it will become obvious to the financial institution the frequency and consistency of such exceptions to the existing definition and prompt adjustments and/or exclusions.  But to try and create the exclusions before collecting the data or examining the actual application volumes is where the futility lies. Best to avoid the futility and act only on actual data.

Further refinement of the segment definition will also be based on the above assessment.  Additional criteria will be added such as:

  • Industry segments (Commercial Real Estate, for example)
  • Product types (construction lending)

Just know that the definition will not stay static.  Based upon the average credit request changes from 2006 to 2010, changes can and will be significant.  The following graph represents the average request amounts from 2010 data compared to the dollar amounts from 2006 (noted below the chart).

Small business market segementation strategies blog post charts

So remember that where you start is not where you have to stay.  Keep measuring, keep adjusting and your segmentation strategy will serve you very well.

Look for my next post on generating small business applications.  Specifically I’ll cover who should be involved in the outbound marketing efforts of your small business segment.

I look forward to your continued comments, challenges and debate as we continue our discussion around small business/business banking.  And if you’re interested, I’m hosting a 3-part Webinar series, Navigating Through The Challenges Affecting Portfolio Performance, that will evaluate how statistics and modeling, combined with strategies from traditional credit management, can create a stronger methodology and protect your bottom line.

Related Posts

How GenAI Fraud Bots Fly Under the Radar (and How to Ground Them Before It’s Too Late)

Today’s AI-powered fraud bots are exceptionally good at mimicking human behavior. Learn why a modern defense strategy is key.

November 18, 2026 by Laura Burrows
What Is Incident Response? Key Steps, Planning and Best Practices

Learn what incident response is, the key steps in the process and how to build and test an incident response plan for a data breach.

November 17, 2026 by Laura Burrows
Rethinking Charged-Off Portfolio Prioritization

Experian’s new Recovery Scores model turns portfolio intelligence into more focused recovery strategies, helping organizations improve returns, direct effort and accelerate speed to cash. The challenge isn’t simply working more accounts. Whether a debt buyer is evaluating an acquisition, an agency is deciding where to assign collector time or a lender is managing its own post-charge-off accounts, the question is similar: How can limited capacity be directed toward accounts with the greatest potential for recovery? Prioritizing accounts mainly by age, balance or when they were last worked may not show which ones are most likely to generate a recovery. With the new Recovery Scores model, organizations can rank charged-off accounts by expected collectability, providing a consistent signal to inform placement strategy and treatment decisions across the recovery lifecycle. Make collector capacity a strategic resource Working every account with the same level of attention isn’t always practical. The more useful question is: Where should teams focus first to protect speed to cash? Our model performance analysis found: 80% of recovered dollars come from the top 40% of accounts worked. The value isn’t simply a better ranking. It’s how organizations can use it for collections optimization. Score bands can inform different strategies for placement, outsourcing, auction and legal channel treatment rather than applying the same approach across an entire portfolio. For debt buyers: The scores can inform acquisition pricing and how a newly purchased portfolio is divided across internal collections, legal channels and resale. Expected collectability can shape debt portfolio analysis, including how a portfolio is valued and segmented before collection work begins. For agencies: Score bands can help teams focus collector resources on accounts with stronger recovery potential. For first-party lenders: Managing recovery internally, the scores provide another signal to help structure decisions about which accounts to work and in what order. Look beyond collectability alone Prioritization rarely comes down to a single variable. Consider two accounts that both rank highly for expected collectability, but one has a substantially larger balance. Their recovery likelihood may be similar, but the potential dollars recovered are not. The Recovery Scores model uses debt collections analytics by combining Experian’s bureau-based score with current balance information. This helps organizations consider both the likelihood of recovery and the potential dollars at stake, while sensitive balance information remains within the organization’s working environment. Monitor accounts as they change The first decision about an account is rarely the last. Teams continually make choices about treatment, placement and resource allocation as accounts move through the recovery process. Recovery Scores is also available as a trigger. When underlying information changes, teams can receive an update and reconsider an account’s placement without waiting for the next portfolio-wide re-score. An account that shows lower recovery potential today may have a different recovery outlook later. Turn recovery potential into a portfolio strategy When portfolios contain more accounts than teams can work at once, the question isn’t simply, “How many accounts can we work?” It is, “Where can our resources have the greatest impact?” The latest Recovery Scores model helps organizations sharpen placement and treatment decisions. It gives debt buyers a way to price and segment portfolios with greater confidence and gives lenders another tool to direct limited collector time across their own post-charge-off portfolios. Learn more about Experian Recovery Scores

November 10, 2026 by Zohreen Ismail

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Enter your name and email for the latest updates.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Don't miss out on the latest industry trends and insights!
Subscribe