Refining Your Debt Collection Process for Optimal Recovery

by Laura Burrows 6 min read May 24, 2023

Breaking down, rethinking, and optimizing your debt collection recovery process can be complicated — but you risk falling behind if you don’t invest in your business. From managing live agents to unlocking the latest machine-learning models, there are different options and routes you can take to improve recovery rates.

Debt collection challenges in 2023

Collection agencies have embraced digitization. The benefits are numerous — cost savings, streamlined processes, and improved compliance, to name a few. However, digital tools aren’t cure-alls, and they can even create new challenges if you’re not careful.

  • Maintaining accurate consumer data: Quickly reaching consumers can be difficult during times of economic uncertainty. Increased access to data can help you overcome this challenge, but only if you can manage and understand the information. If you simply turn on the metaphorical data streams, you could find yourself drowning in duplicate and erroneous entries.
  • Keeping up with rising delinquencies: Delinquency rates steadily rose throughout 2022.1 Although rates may level out for some types of accounts in 2023, collection agencies need a plan for dealing with the potential increased volume. At the same time, continued low unemployment rates could make it difficult to hire and retain agents. 
  • Managing a tight budget: Recession worries also have companies rethinking expenses, which can impact your ability to increase head count and invest in technology. Finding effective trade-offs is going to be important for debt collection process optimization.
  • Staying compliant: We’ve seen some major changes over the last few years, but there’s no time to rest — debt collectors always need to be aware of new state and federal regulations. Digitization might make compliance more difficult if you’re now managing an increasing amount of personal information or using text messages (or other omni-channels) to contact consumers.

WATCH:Keeping pace with collections compliance changes

Five ways to enhance your debt collection process

Here are five ways that debt collectors can overcome today’s challenges and take advantage of new opportunities.

1. Leverage clean data

Continuously updating and checking the accuracy of your data can help increase right-party contact rates. But don’t rely on your internal data and basic internet searches or public records. Leading data and skip-tracing services can give you access to additional data from credit bureaus, alternative financial services, collateral records, business listings and other helpful sources.

Some skip-tracing tools can continuously verify and update contact information. They can also rank contact records, such as phone numbers, to save your agent’s time. And identify consumers in a protected status such as bankrupt, deceased, and active military) and require special handling to help you stay compliant.

2. Implement advanced analytics and automation

High-quality data can also be the foundation for a data-driven approach to collections.

  • Use collections-specific models: Although credit risk scores can be a piece of the debt collection puzzle, debt collection recovery models are often a better fit. You may be able to use different models to score accounts based on exposure, risk, willingness to pay or behavioral factors.
  • Segment accounts: Increased insights and models also allow you to more precisely segment accounts, which can help you handle larger volumes with fewer resources. For instance, you can more accurately determine which accounts require an agent’s personal touch, which can move forward with an automated experience and which should go to the back of your queue. 

The data-driven approach also allows you to increasingly automate your collections — which can help you deal with rising delinquency rates in the face of a tight labor market and budget constraints.

3. Know when and how to make contact

Segmentation and advanced analytics can tell you who and when to contact, but you also have to be mindful of how you reach out. Letters, calls, emails and texts can all be effective in the right circumstances, but no single option will always be best. For example, a text could be ideal when contacting Gen Z, but a call might work best for Baby Boomers.

That’s neither novel nor surprising, but it is important to stay up to date with the latest trends and preferences. Ideally, you reach people on their preferred channel at an appropriate time. You may also need to continually test, monitor and refine your process, especially if you want to increase automation.

READ:Digital Debt Collection Future white paper

4. Offer financially appropriate treatments

In addition to picking the right communication channel, consider the payment options you offer consumers. Various payment plans, settlements and policies can directly affect your recovery rates — and what performed best in previous years might not make sense anymore.

Chatbots and virtual negotiators can also help improve recovery rates without straining your agents’ time. And for accounts that will likely self-cure, automated texts or emails with links to self-service portals could be an ideal solution. Expanding payment methods, such as accepting payments from digital wallets when you’re sending a text message, could also make sense.

However, you want to be sure you’re not wasting time or money by contacting consumers who don’t have the means to make a payment. Instead, set those accounts aside for now, but monitor them for changes that could indicate their financial situation has changed — such as a new credit line. Then, try to offer a solution that will likely fit the consumer’s circumstances.

5. Invest in your live agents

Modern debt management and collection systems focus on digitization and automation, and these can improve recovery rates. But don’t forget about your front-line agents.

There will always be times when a personal touch gets you further than an automated message. Continued training and ongoing recognition can be important for retaining top performers, maintaining compliance and increasing agents’ effectiveness.

Partner for success

Implementing an efficient and effective collections strategy can require a lot of work, but you don’t have to go at it alone. Experian offers various debt collection solutions that can help optimize processes and free up your organization’s resources and agents’ time.

Tap into our industry-leading data sources — including traditional credit data, alternative financial data and over 5,000 local phone exchange carriers — to find, update and verify account information. Available on the cloud or with secure file transfers, the TrueTrace™ and TrueTrace Live™ tools have led to a 10 percent lift in right-party contact rates compared to competitors. When it comes to optimizing outreach, you can prioritize accounts with over 60 industry-specific debt recovery scores via PriorityScore for CollectionsSM. Or work with Experian to create custom models for your organization.

For an end-to-end decisioning solution, our AI-driven Experian Decisioning solution draws from internal and external data to determine the proper customer contact frequency, channel and treatment options, including self-service portals. Create your own strategies and workflows and manage the entire process with a single dashboard, cloud-based access and integrated reports.

1Experian. (February 2023). Credit Scores Steady as Consumer Debt Balances Rise in 2022

Related Posts

Vision 2026 day one recap: Designing what’s next 

Day one of Vision 2026 brought big ideas to the stage and practical conversations to life across the conference.  From conversations about trust and AI to breakout sessions, hands-on experiences in the Innovation Arena and connections throughout San Antonio, leaders from across the industry came together to explore the technologies, strategies and opportunities shaping what’s next.  Welcome to Vision 2026: Jeff Softley  Jeff Softley, CEO of Experian North America, welcomed attendees with a look at the growing importance of trust as AI becomes a more active participant in business and decision-making.  He announced Experian Cashflow Data Bureau, Inc, a new consumer reporting agency (CRA) that operates under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), enabling financial institutions to leverage consumer-permissioned cash flow insights at scale to help support more informed underwriting decisions and responsibly expand access to credit. Softley emphasized how trusted data, technology and connections can come together to create greater opportunity and meaningful outcomes for consumers and businesses. Reflecting on the growing role of AI agents, Softley explored how organizations can lead as intelligence becomes a more active participant in decision-making, emphasizing the importance of trust, scalability and accountability.  Data isn't scarce anymore. Trust is.Jeff Softley, CEO of Experian North America Softley also explored how connecting trusted data in new ways can help businesses make smarter decisions and create greater opportunities for consumers. His opening remarks set the stage for a day focused on embracing greater intelligence while maintaining the trust needed to turn possibility into meaningful outcomes.  Designing Tomorrow: Molly Poppie and Kathleen Peters  Next, Molly Poppie, Chief Product & Analytics Officer, Experian North America, and Kathleen Peters, Chief Innovation Officer, Experian North America, took the stage for Designing Tomorrow.  They explored how trusted data, advanced analytics and seamless workflows can help organizations navigate an increasingly agentic world, make smarter decisions and drive resilient growth.  Trust remained central to the conversation, particularly as AI agents become more prevalent. Poppie and Peters explored digital identity and human-to-agent connections, including how organizations can establish trust between an agent and the person behind it.  They also looked at how bringing together the right data, logic and technology can reduce guesswork, make interactions smarter and accelerate new capabilities. As disruption creates both risk and opportunity, organizations have an opportunity to design what comes next with trust built in from the start.  Day 1 keynote: A conversation with Ethan Mollick  Day one keynote speaker Ethan Mollick, Innovation Expert and Artificial Intelligence Thought Leader; Professor of Entrepreneurship at The Wharton School, explored the evolving relationship between people and AI.  Through live demonstrations, he examined how working effectively with AI calls for many of the same skills that make strong managers — providing direction, context and judgment while keeping people at the center.  As AI becomes increasingly capable, Mollick explored what it means to keep people involved in the process. The conversation reinforced the continued importance of human expertise and judgment even as AI takes on increasingly complex tasks.  From big ideas to practical action  Beyond the main stage, day one breakout sessions gave attendees the opportunity to dig deeper into some of the biggest questions facing businesses today.  Conversations explored practical AI roadmaps and trust frameworks for agentic ecosystems, new approaches to fraud prevention, and how better data and analytics can support smarter lending decisions.  Other sessions examined the growing role of nontraditional data in expanding credit access, fairness by design in AI underwriting, real-time prescreen, AI-powered connected intelligence and smarter approaches to pre-delinquency management.  Across topics, a common theme emerged: turning rapidly evolving technology, data and intelligence into practical strategies that can help organizations make smarter decisions and create better outcomes.  Innovation in action  Innovation was on full display in the Innovation Arena, with 27 demos bringing Experian’s latest capabilities to life and creating opportunities to connect directly with the experts behind them.  From AI-driven decisioning and fraud prevention to growth and operational resilience, the Arena offered a hands-on look at how emerging capabilities can help address real business challenges.  Connections beyond the conference floor  After a full day of ideas and innovation, attendees stepped away from the conference floor for networking activities across San Antonio.  From exploring the city’s food scene and taking in the Alamo and River Walk to a pickleball showdown, Texas BBQ tour, golf at TPC San Antonio and more, attendees had the opportunity to continue conversations, meet new people and build connections with peers, industry leaders and Experian experts.  The afternoon offered a chance to turn conversations started inside the conference into connections that extend well beyond it — a defining part of the Vision experience.  Celebrating innovation at Vision after dark  The connections continue tonight at Vision after dark, beginning with recognition of the 2026 Vision Award winners.  The Vision Awards celebrate organizations accelerating action and driving meaningful change, spotlighting the people and organizations putting innovation into practice. Then, renowned mentalist and magician Asi Wind takes the stage for an unforgettable performance filled with mystery, audience participation and unexpected moments.  It’s a fitting way to close a day centered on new ideas, unexpected perspectives and meaningful connections.  Up next: Day two  Day one may be over, but there’s plenty more ahead. Get ready for another day of big ideas, practical insights and memorable connections at Vision 2026. 

October 6, 2026 by Sharis Rostamian
Ask the Expert: Busting the Biggest Myths About Alternative Data with David Elmore and Vince Nowicki

Alternative data myths can hold lenders back. Experian and Mission Federal bust common misconceptions about risk, implementation and getting started.

October 5, 2026 by Julie Lee
2026-2027 Data Breach Response Guide

Our Data Breach Response Guide provides guidance to help your organization prepare, respond and recover while protecting your customers.

September 30, 2026 by Laura Burrows

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Enter your name and email for the latest updates.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Don't miss out on the latest industry trends and insights!
Subscribe