Loading...

Consumers Continue to Shift Preferences Toward Used Vehicles

Published: January 27, 2020 by Melinda Zabritski

Car dealer with couple in showroom

It’s no surprise that affordability continues to be top of mind for consumers who are in-market for a vehicle. As average vehicle loan amounts and monthly payments continue to climb, consumer preferences are shifting to used vehicles as they look to maintain their financial health.

According to Experian’s Q3 2019 State of the Automotive Finance Market report, used vehicle financing increased across all credit tiers, from 53.86 percent in Q3 2018 to 55.15 percent in Q3 2019. The most notable increase was in super prime originations, which increased 3.3 percent to 13.42 percent during the quarter.

During Q3 2019, 55 percent of used vehicle loans were composed of consumers with prime and super prime credit which is the highest percentage of consumers since Q3 2009. Consumers are still opting for longer payment terms whether they opt for a new or used vehicle. The average used loan term was 64.89 months and new vehicles were an average term of 69.28 months.

Another trend seen in the Q3 2019 data was a shift among super prime and prime consumers in where they chose to shop for vehicles. Independent dealers showed an increase of prime and super prime financing, coming in at 37.92 percent of loans in Q3 2019, compared to 34.87 percent a year ago. Independent dealers also saw an increase in average used loan terms, from 60.86 months in Q3 2018, to 62.59 months in Q3 2019.

Average vehicle loan amounts continued to grow, as did monthly payments. The average new vehicle loan amount was $32,480, with an average monthly payment of $550. For used vehicles, the average loan amount reached $20,466, with a $393 payment.

One of the key factors in prime and super prime consumers shifting to used vehicles is likely an increase in availability of late-model used vehicles created by continued popularity of leasing. (Leasing accounted for 28.76 percent of new vehicles in Q3 2019.) These vehicles are typically recent enough to have similar features to newer models, but at a lower price. That said, late-model used vehicles can still be expensive, which is likely why we’re seeing an uptick in super prime and prime consumers opting for financing and longer terms, since those longer terms are one way to decrease monthly payments.

As consumers shop for vehicles with their financial health in mind, it’s not surprising to see prime and super prime preferences shift toward used vehicles. Lenders and dealers can leverage these trends to ensure they have the right options available to help consumers make the best decision for their budget.

To view the entire Q3 2019 State of the Automotive Finance Market report, or to watch the webinar, visit https://www.experian.com/automotive/automotive-webinars.html

Related Posts

Day 1 of Vision 2025 is in the books – and what a start. From bold keynotes to breakout sessions and networking under the Miami sun, the energy and inspiration were undeniable.  A wave of change: Jeff Softley opens Vision 2025  The day kicked off with a powerful keynote from Jeff Softley, Experian North America CEO, who issued a call to action for the industry: to not just adapt to change, but to lead it.  “It isn’t a ripple – it’s a tidal wave of technology,” Jeff said. “Together we ride this wave with confidence.”  His keynote set the tone for a day centered on innovation and the future of financial services – where technology, insight and trust converge to create lasting impact. Jeff continues this conversation in the latest Experian Exchange episode, where he explores three forces shaping the industry: the rise of AI, the demand for personalized digital experiences and the mission to expand credit access for all.  Turning vision into action: Alex Lintner on agentic AI  Building on Jeff’s message, Alex Lintner, CEO of Experian Software and Technology, took the stage to show how Experian is turning innovation into measurable results. His keynote explored how agentic and advanced AI capabilities are redefining financial services ROI and powering the next generation of the Ascend Platform™.  For a deeper look into how Experian is reshaping the economics of credit and fraud decisioning, read the latest American Banker feature.  Unfiltered insights from “Mr. Wonderful”  The day’s highlight came from Kevin O’Leary, investor, entrepreneur and the always-candid “Mr. Wonderful.” With his trademark wit and honesty, Kevin shared sharp insights on thriving in a disruptive economy, offering candid advice on leadership, risk and opportunity. He even gave attendees a peek behind the Shark Tank curtain, revealing a few surprises and the mindset that drives his bold business decisions.  Breakouts that inspired and informed  The conference floor buzzed with energy as attendees joined breakout sessions on fraud defense, AI-driven personalization, regulatory trends and consumer insights. Sessions highlighted how Experian’s unified value proposition is fueling double-digit growth, how to future-proof credit risk strategies and how data and innovation are redefining customer engagement across the lifecycle.   Hands-on innovation and connection  The Innovation Showcase gave attendees an up-close look at Experian’s latest tools and technologies in action. Meanwhile, friendly competition kept the excitement high through the Vision mobile app leaderboard – with every check-in and connection earning points toward the top spot.  Networking beyond the conference hall walls  As the sun set, Vision 2025 shifted into high gear with unforgettable networking events across Miami – from golf at the Miller Course to art walks, brewery tours and a scenic cruise through Biscayne Bay.   An evening to remember  The day closed with the first-ever Vision Awards Dinner, celebrating standout leaders who are shaping the future of financial services.   Up Next: Day 2  The momentum continues tomorrow as more keynote speakers take the stage. Stay tuned for more insights, innovation, and inspiration from Vision 2025. 

Published: October 7, 2025 by Stefani Wendel

In an ever-evolving automotive landscape, where shifting consumer behavior meets fluctuating market dynamics, Experian’s State of the Automotive Finance Market Report: Q2 2025 delivers key insights into how both consumers and professionals are adapting to the changes. This quarter’s report revealed a sharp increase in vehicle refinancing—up nearly 70% from Q2 2024—as consumers capitalized on the more stable rate environment. In fact, after refinancing, the average interest rate went from 10.45% to 8.45%. That shift resulted in their monthly payment dropping by an average of $71. Interestingly, credit unions played a significant role in the refinance surge, increasing their market share from 63.22% last year to 68.33% this quarter, and borrowers who refinanced through credit unions saw their monthly payments decrease by $87 on average. Banks saw a slight dip in their share of the refinancing market year-over-year, going from 22.71% to 21.45%, and borrowers who refinanced through them saved an average of $46 a month. New leaders emerge as the lender market share continues to evolve Taking a deeper dive into the automotive finance market share, banks reclaimed their leading position for total vehicle financing, rising to 27.50% in Q2 2025, from 24.50% in Q2 2024. Meanwhile, captives declined from 30.17% to 26.63% year-over-year, and credit unions slightly increased from 20.35% to 21.04% during the same period. For new vehicles, captives continued to lead at 52.39% this quarter, though it was a drop from 60.74% last year. On the other hand, banks grew from 21.12% to 25.91% and credit unions went from 9.99% to 12.24% in the same time frame. On the used side, banks edged ahead, increasing their share to 28.59% in Q2 2025, from 26.80% last year. Credit unions saw slight growth from 27.59% to 27.63%, while captives declined from 7.83% to 6.40% year-over-year. As affordability remains a key priority, consumers seem to be exploring financing options that offer more favorable terms. While Experian Automotive’s report continues to illustrate the evolving dynamics, these data-driven insights can empower both consumers and industry professionals to make smarter financial decisions. To learn more about automotive finance trends, view the full State of the Automotive Finance Market Report: Q2 2025 presentation on demand.

Published: September 5, 2025 by Melinda Zabritski

Tenant screening fraud is rising, with falsified paystubs and AI-generated documents driving risk. Learn how income and employment verification tools powered by observed data improve fraud detection, reduce costs, and streamline tenant screening.

Published: September 4, 2025 by Ted Wentzel

Subscribe to our Auto blog

Enter your name and email for the latest updates.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.