Loading...

Are We Suffering from Breach Notification Fatigue?

Published: May 3, 2011 by Guest Contributor

It seems as though every day the news headlines trumpet another high-profile data breach. The most recent marquee breach is courtesy of a Sony PlayStation Network hacker, whose attack on the Sony and Qriocity servers between April 17th and 19th have compromised the personal data and, possibly, stored credit card information of 77 million players. (Yes, you read that right; 77 million.) Combine that with other recent cyber-heists affecting millions of unsuspecting consumers or residents, and many organizations have been forced to send out a dizzying array of email notifications to their customer base, many – if not all – of whom are now vulnerable to spear-phishing attacks.

With numerous different breaches affecting so many people as of late, millions of consumers are receiving emails from trusted brands noting that customer emails (and perhaps other information) have been compromised, so consumers should be wary of future emails that may appear to be sent from them…like the one they’re reading now.

Got that?

This begs the question of whether customers are starting to tune out to the onslaught of breach alerts flooding their email in-boxes.

Some security gurus believe that notifications aren’t effective and customers become numb to these alerts. Others are convinced that breach information overload is a good thing, educating people to the dangers lurking in the cybershadows and their vulnerability to identity thieves. After all, how do you know to watch out for email “bait” if you’re not aware there’s a phishing hook with your name on it?

Furthermore, the flip side of over-notification is under-notification. This is something that Sony is now being accused of in a lawsuit that claims the company waited too long to notify its PlayStation customers of the recent breach, which only exacerbated customer vulnerability to credit card fraud.

The irony is that while the dramatic breaches of late have been stealing headlines (as well as data), a 2011 Data Breaches Investigations Report by Verizon indicates that total thefts from data breaches have in fact declined significantly over the past few years. The total number of records actually compromised from these breaches was a “mere” 4 million in 2010, quite a drop from the 144 million records compromised in 2009, and the 361 million compromised records in 2008. The bad news? If you look at actual data breaches versus compromised records, the numbers this year are up; 760 breaches last year, an increase from 141 in 2009.

The bottom line: while fraudsters haven’t been able to recently score as much cyber-loot as in times past, this is no time to relax. Just be aware that with the steep increase in breaches comes an equally steep increase in breach notifications, and the associated risk that breach notification fatigue will put your customers to sleep.

Related Posts

Learn what lending fraud is, what you can do to safeguard your organization and consumers and how we can help. Read more!

Published: August 7, 2025 by Laura Burrows

Data breaches continue to be a reality for organizations across industries, and the complexity of responding to them is only increasing. From AI-driven fraud to third-party exposures, the risk landscape is shifting fast. Having a modern and tested response plan is essential to containing the damage, protecting your customers, and preserving your organization’s reputation when a breach occurs. Experian’s eleventh annual Data Breach Response Guide draws on decades of breach support experience. It offers practical strategies and insights for navigating the moments that matter most: the first hours after a breach and the days that follow. The 2025–2026 guide explores: How AI is shaping new breach and fraud patterns Where organizations are most vulnerable, including third-party and supply chain weak points Consumer expectations and how they influence crisis response How prepared organizations are reducing impact and protecting trust What is required to build a modern, effective breach response plan Organizations with a tested plan can potentially reduce the cost, impact, and long-term consequences of a breach. From real-world case insights to crisis communication templates, this guide is designed to help teams act quickly and confidently. Download the 2025–2026 Data Breach Response Guide to learn how you can strengthen your breach preparedness, reduce risk exposure, and build resilience against the next wave of cybersecurity threats. Download guide

Published: August 4, 2025 by Julie Lee

Experian is proud to be a Thought Leadership Sponsor at this year’s Federal Identity Forum & Expo. Meet us on site at FedID!

Published: August 1, 2025 by Kim Le