How the Pandemic Affected Unemployment Insurance Benefits

April 25, 2023 by Vikki Chaffin

When faced with the challenges of the global COVID-19 pandemic, the U.S. government used unemployment insurance benefits to mitigate its potentially devastating effects on its citizens and the overall economy. The response was swift and significant – not only did the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act expand eligibility for UI to those who otherwise would not have been able to claim it, but it also extended the duration of benefits and increased the benefit amounts. Thanks to this assistance, the social safety net provided vital support to many families in need, boosted spending, and helped individuals weather tough circumstances.

Unemployment Insurance Benefits Transformed During the Coronavirus Pandemic

The unemployment insurance system, as a financial partnership between the federal and state governments, aims to provide limited-time assistance to individuals in case of involuntary job loss, provided they continue to actively seek employment whilst receiving benefits. In most states, the length of UI benefits does not exceed 26 weeks, and the amount awarded replaces 30 to 50 percent of the wages.

The pandemic caused a shift and expansion of UI eligibility. Faced with unprecedented challenges, the legislators enacted the Pandemic Unemployment Assistance (PUA) program, which included self-employed people, contractors, and freelancers as the UI compensation beneficiaries, all of whom faced financial hardships due to the pandemic and loss of jobs.

Additional legislation tackled the amounts awarded to all the employees affected by pandemics. Federal Pandemic Unemployment Compensation (FPUC), added $600 per week to unemployment benefits, which, in December 2020, were reduced to a $300 weekly bonus, extended until September 2021 by the American Rescue Plan (ARP). The ARP was responsible for the tax exemption of the first $10,200 in unemployment insurance benefits for all with income below $150,000.

The provisions of the Pandemic Emergency Unemployment Compensation (PEUC) program extended the duration of unemployment insurance benefits payments first by 13 weeks, and then to 24 weeks above the already stipulated maximum set by states. When the PEUC expired in September 2021, the maximum length of UI benefits was 53 weeks.

Expiry of Pandemic UI Programs in 2021

Twenty-four states stopped the pandemic unemployment compensation programs mid-year, to encourage workers to return to the labor market and allow employers to reestablish control over business operations, since, even then, the new reality was to be faced, sooner or later. By September 2021, the unemployment programs initiated through the CARES Act expired in all the states.

The evidence showed that early termination of the UI programs helped in reducing the unemployment insurance benefits claims as well as employment growth. At that point, with the pandemic still going on, these programs ended up completing their mission: to be a lifeline in a serious global crisis. Along with some other policies enforced by federal and state authorities, it made the costs of living without a job or with reduced working hours bearable for millions of jobless workforce members and their households.

Changed UI Landscape

The UI programs created during the pandemic were never intended to be permanent. Still, their effects outlasted them. Among other things, they exposed both the strengths and weaknesses of the UI system, lifting the veil off of some categories of workers more vulnerable than others in times of joblessness.

Some reports showed a lack of incentive to seek work after receiving unemployment insurance benefits for a long period. Others point to faults in the system allowing for overpayments and false claims that need to be fixed and upgraded to prevent such oversights in the future.

On the whole, it was an incredibly expensive financial undertaking causing a major imbalance in public finances that would need to be remedied in the years to come. One of the ways the federal government is making sure funds will be replaced is by imposing FUTA credit reduction for several states which took out loans to fund the UI benefits in this period.

States are also taking measures to reinstate stability, bring back jobs and decrease reliance on unemployment insurance benefits. Legislators in several states debated the possibility to decrease the duration of benefits and reduce the weekly benefit amounts. Currently, Massachusetts awards the largest weekly amount of $823, and the lowest, amounting to $235 in Mississippi.

Employers Face Great Challenges in Post-COVID-19 Era

The COVID-19 pandemic put an enormous burden on both the federal government and the state unemployment insurance systems, imposing changes to the way UI systems worked and modifications of typical operations. The economic downturn amidst the pandemic disaster hit employers particularly hard, not only because the entire system got turned upside down, but also because it created additional obligations and costs to bear long after the pandemic.

The increased tax rates are already a reality. Employers may see the trend to continue until the overall system has stabilized. In such a situation it is evident that every opportunity to save on unemployment insurance costs needs to be recognized and fully utilized. This includes keeping a keen eye on UI claims and making prudent decisions to contest them when appropriate to prevent your SUTA tax rate from rising unnecessarily. Outsourcing and automating operations in this area helps employers keep up with the ongoing tumultuous environment. Employers can rely on automated unemployment claims management to evaluate, contest and protest UI claims. The solution from Experian Employer Services improves compliance with the ever-changing rules and regulations at both the federal and state levels, allowing significant savings in time and resources in the long run.

About Us

We brought together the best of the best to deliver a suite of specialized solutions with unmatched service, trusted expertise and client-inspired innovation. We’re focused on the employee experience while improving your bottom line. Reduce complexity and minimize disruption with Experian Employer Services.

We’re keeping the focus and flexibility you value in boutique providers and adding the resources and security of Experian.