Stop Trying to Collect from Synthetic Identities

by Guest Contributor 4 min read July 15, 2019

Friend or foe?

Sophisticated criminals put a great deal of effort into creating convincing, verifiable personas (AKA synthetic identities). Once the fictional customer has embedded itself in your business, everything from the acquisition of financial instruments to healthcare benefits, utility services, and tax filings and refunds become vulnerable to synthetic identity fraud.

Information attached to synthetic IDs can run several levels deep and be so complete that it includes public record data, credit information, documentary evidence and social media profiles that may even contain photo sets and historical details intended to deceive—all complicating your efforts to identify these fake customers before you do business with them.

See real-world examples of how synthetic identity fraud is souring various markets – from auto and healthcare to financial services and public sector – in our tip sheet, Four common synthetic scenarios.

Stopping synthetic ID fraud — at the door and thereafter.

There are efforts underway in the market to collectively improve your ability to identify, shut down and prevent synthetic identities from entering your portfolio. This overall trend is great news for the future, but there are also near-term solutions you can apply to protect your business starting now. While it’s important to identify synthetic identities when they knock on your door, it’s just as important to conduct regular portfolio checkups to prevent negative impacts to your collections efforts. Every circumstance has its own unique parameters, but the overarching steps necessary to mitigate fraud from synthetic IDs remain the same:

  1. Identify current and near-term exposure using targeted segmentation analysis.
  2. Apply technology that alerts you when identity data doesn’t add up.
  3. Differentiate fraudulent identities from those simply based on bad data.
  4. Review front- and back-end screening procedures until they satisfy best practices.
  5. Achieve a “single view of the customer” for all account holders across access channels—online, mobile, call center and face-to-face.

The right tools for the job.

In addition to the steps mentioned above, stopping these fake customers from entering and then stealing from your organization isn’t easy—but with the right tools and strategies, it is possible. Here are a few of our top recommendations:

Forensics

Isolate and segment identities based on signals received during early account pathing, from both individuals and their device. For example, even sophisticated fraud networks can’t mimic natural per-device user interaction because these organizations work with hundreds or thousands of synthetic identities using just a few devices. It’s highly unlikely that multiple geographically separate account holders would share the same physical device.

High-risk fraud scores

Not all synthetic identity fraud manifests the same way. Using sophisticated logic and unique combinations of data, a high-risk fraud score looks at a consumer’s credit behavior and credit relationships over time to uncover previously undetectable risk. These scores are especially successful in detecting identities that are products of synthetic identity farms. And by targeting a specific data set and relationships, you can maintain a frictionless customer experience and reduce false positives.

Analytics

Use a solution that develops models of bad applicant behavior, then compares and scores your portfolio against these models. There isn’t a single rule for detecting fraudulent identities, but you can develop an informed set of rules and targeted models with the right service partner. Cross-referencing models designed to isolate high-risk identity theft cases, first-party or true-name fraud schemes, and synthetic identities can be accomplished in a decisioning strategy or via a custom model that incorporates the aggregate scores and attributes holistically.

Synthetic identity detection rules

These specialized rules consist of numerous conditions that evaluate a broad selection of consumer behaviors. When they occur in specific combinations, these behaviors indicate synthetic identity fraud. This broad-based approach provides a comprehensive evaluation of an identity to more effectively determine if it’s fabricated. It also helps reduce the incidence of inaccurately associating a real identity with a fictitious one, providing a better customer experience.

Work streams

Address synthetic identities confidently by applying analytics to work streams throughout the customer life cycle:

  • Credit risk assessment
  • Know Your Customer/Customer Identification Program checks
  • Risk-based identity proofing and authentication
  • Existing account management
  • Manual reviews, investigations and charge-offs/collections activities

Learn more about these tools and others that can help you mitigate synthetic identities in our white paper, Synthetic identities: getting real with customers.

If your organization is like most, detecting SIDs hasn’t been your top priority. So, there’s no time to waste in preventing them from entering your portfolio. Criminals are highly motivated to innovate their approaches as rapidly as possible, and it’s important to implement a solution that addresses the continued rise of synthetic IDs from multiple engagement points.

With the right set of analytics and decisioning tools, you can reduce exposure to fraud and losses stemming from synthetic identity attacks from the beginning and across the customer life cycle. We can help you detect and mitigate these fake customers before they become delinquent. Learn more

Related Posts

Ask the Expert: The Future of Lending Starts With Identity With Shawn Rife and Brian Cardona

Identity intelligence and alternative data can help lenders validate consumers and support more informed decisions across the customer lifecycle.

September 16, 2026 by Julie Lee
Financial Institutions Are Rethinking Customer Acqusition

Customer acquisition strategies are constantly evolving toward more precise targeting. From a marketing lens, you can track every step, optimize communication channels and still miss the person most likely to convert. Attribution can tell us which channels work and automation can make marketing spend more efficient. But both assume we know who is actually on the other end. Financial institutions are learning that finding audiences and targeting them is no longer the biggest challenge. As acquisition optimization marketing becomes more sophisticated, teams can measure and act on more signals than before. What they can't always know is whether the person on the receiving end is real. Customer acquisition has evolved into an identity problem. The challenge is not that every questionable signal represents malicious activity. It's that acquisition systems must make increasingly intelligent decisions with an imperfect understanding of who they're actually engaging. When identities are fragmented, duplicated, temporary or synthetic, optimization becomes a question of trust as much as targeting. When your signals don't reliably identify customers The customer journey often includes searching, filling out a form, creating an account, requesting a quote and subscribing. All of these signals work well when identity is relatively stable.  However, financial institutions are finding that these signals are becoming less reliable. A single person can operate across multiple personas, devices, browsers, aliases, accounts and intermediaries while several apparent “people” may actually represent one underlying actor. Financial instituions are finding: Fragmented customer signals Difficulty distinguishing an old account from a new one Different digital pathways associated with the same individual Signals that are generated by automation Real customers getting flagged because signals are too thin to evaluate confidently Legacy signals continue to be challenged Marketing has historically treated intent as a valuable signal because intent was relatively difficult to produce. A search required human intent. A form required someone to fill it out. An inquiry implied a meaningful amount of human effort. Financial institutions are already combating AI-enabled fraud, and now marketing teams are starting to face it on a massive scale. AI can mimic human behavior by researching products, comparing prices, filling out forms, creating accounts and signing up for services. A valid email address is no longer enough. Marketers need to know: How long has it existed? How recently has it been active? Does its activity appear consistent or suddenly anomalous? Has it gone dormant and returned? Is it associated with patterns that suggest stability or unusual behavior? How to build on your strongest signal Email remains one of the most persistent identifiers in digital commerce, following people across devices, platforms, transactions, subscriptions, accounts and years of activity. For over two decades, this has shaped how AtData thinks about identity. Now, as part of Experian, it’s shaping how an entire platform and team approach identity. A marketer doesn’t need every prospect to have existed online for twenty years. But understanding whether a newly acquired prospect has meaningful identity context can dramatically improve the quality of the decision being made around it. Better identity intelligence can help organizations reduce unnecessary friction by improving their ability to recognize legitimate customers. With a strong identity foundation, marketing teams can better address: Which audiences are more likely to convert? Which leads are high quality? Which channels are driving incremental growth? What do the best prospects look like? The value isn't simply having an email address. It's understanding the history and behavioral context associated with it. That context can provide a stronger digital identity signal, helping marketers understand how long they have been active, whether its behavior is consistent with that of a real person and whether current activity aligns with past patterns. It continues to be one of the most persistent identifiers in digital commerce. An infrastructure built for what's coming The acquisition of AtData by Experian reflects a fundamental shift in how identity infrastructure needs to work. Experian's scale and decisioning capabilities, combined with AtData's real-time email intelligence, create a strong platform. Read more about the why behind the acquisition and see how email works as an identity anchor for fraud prevention. Contact us to learn about our customer acquisition solutions

September 15, 2026 by Zohreen Ismail
As Electric Vehicle Adoption Eases, Dealers Can Find New Opportunities To Reach Consumers

After years of rapid growth, new electric vehicle (EV) registrations have moderated, and the EV market has entered a new chapter. But slower growth shouldn’t be mistaken for disappearing demand, with data suggesting the reality is much more nuanced. According to Experian Automotive’s Automotive Consumer Trends Report: Q2 2026, battery EVs accounted for 8.21% of new retail registrations in the last 12 months, down from 9.23% a year earlier. However, consumers aren’t simply walking away from electrification. In fact, more than one million new EVs were registered during the past 12 months and the used EV market recorded more than 540,000 registrations over the same period. The opportunity may be less about waiting for the EV market to grow and more about understanding where EV demand is present, who is driving them, and how to reach those consumers more effectively. Who is likely to purchase an EV and what vehicle types are they interested in? Understanding who’s in the market for an EV can allow dealers to position themselves around consumers’ needs as they choose a vehicle that fits their everyday lifestyle. In the second quarter of 2026, Millennials and Gen X accounted for 67.83% of new EV registrations, nearly 10 percentage points above their combined share of all new, retail registrations. Millennials were also the largest generational audience across both new and used EV market share, coming in at 35.76% and 38.42%, respectively. It’s important to consider that the EV shopper isn’t necessarily looking for an unfamiliar or new type of vehicle. In many cases, they’re seemingly looking for an electric version of the practical vehicle they already know. For instance, SUVs accounted for 77.47% of new EV registrations in Q2 2026, which was similar to SUVs’ 63.49% share of all new retail registrations. For these shoppers, creating messaging around value, practicality, and available choices may resonate differently than premium technology messaging aimed at some new-EV prospects. The more precisely dealers can identify those audiences, the less they need to depend on broad EV market momentum to generate demand. To learn more about EV insights, view the full Automotive Consumer Trends Report: Q2 2026 presentation.

September 15, 2026 by Kirsten Von Busch

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Enter your name and email for the latest updates.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Don't miss out on the latest industry trends and insights!
Subscribe