In Search of the Ideal Member

by Guest Contributor 6 min read December 16, 2019

It’s December, and if you’re like most credit union leaders, your strategic plan is distributed, and the 2020 budget is approved. Before you know it, you and your team will be off and running to pursue the New Year’s goals. Another thing most of us have in common is a strategic membership growth priority. New members are needed to help us take loan and deposit growth to the next level.

Specifically, who are you looking for?

It’s surprising how many credit union leaders have a difficult time clarifying their ideal member(s). They usually come up short after they have called out younger borrowers, active checking account users, prime credit, middle income, homeowners, etc. The reality is in today’s competitive market, these general audiences are not definitive enough. Many then go to market with a limited universe that is too generic to be highly effective.

Savvy marketers have a much deeper understanding of who they are reaching and why. First, they have clearly defined the ideal member i.e. product profitability, relationship profitability, referrals, how they access the credit union, etc. Second, they use data, analytics and demographic segmenting to refine their search further to reveal the ideal member.

They leverage information to understand what drives the potential members decision making. They understand that every potential member does not live the same type of life. They segment markets into groups to understand their shared values and life experiences. These segments include geographic, demographic, financial behavior, and motivation that includes psychographics and social values. Thus, armed with this information, they align the consumer’s needs with the credit union’s products, purpose and strategic goals. This clarity allows them to invest their marketing dollars for the best possible result.

Most credit unions would identify “younger borrowers” as a desired member, so we’ve laid out two examples of just how different this member can look.

Ambitious Singles – is a demographic segment comprised of younger cutting-edge singles living in mid-scale, metro areas that balance work and leisure lifestyles.

  • Annual Median income $75k – $100K
  • Highly educated
  • First time home buyers
  • Professionals, upwardly mobile
  • Channel preferences for engaging with brands (and their offers) is while watching or streaming TV, listening to their favorite radio apps or while browsing the web on their phones. They are also quite email receptive (but subject lines must be compelling)

Families Matter Most – This segment is comprised of young middle-class families in scenic suburbs, leading family focused lives.

  • Annual Median income $75K – $99K
  • Have children 4-6 yrs. old
  • Educated
  • Homeowners
  • Child-related purchases
  • Credit revolver and auto borrowers (larger vehicles)
  • Go online for banking, telecommuting and shopping

Both segments represent younger borrowers with similar incomes, but they have different loan needs, lifestyle priorities and preferences for engaging with a marketing offer. These are just two examples of the segmentation data that is available from Experian.

The segmentation solution provides a framework to help credit unions identify the optimal customer investment strategy for each member segment. This framework helps the credit union optimize their marketing between differentiating segments. For some segments the investment may be directed toward finding the ideal member. Others may be made to find depositors. While many credit unions don’t have infinite marketing budgets or analytical resources, segmentation help marketers more efficiently and effectively pursue the best member or develop member personas to better resonate with existing members. The feedback we have heard from credit union leaders is that the solution is the best segmentation tool they have seen. Learn more about it here.

What your team is up against

Today, credit unions face national competitors that are using state-of-the-art data analytics, first-rate technology and in-depth market segmentation to promote very attractive offers to win new members, deposits, checking accounts and loans. Their offers have a look, feel, message and offer that are relevant to the person receiving the offer. Here are a few recent “offer” examples that we have heard of that should give you pause:

  • Fintech companies, like the Lending Club offering auto loan refinances (the offer provides an estimate of refinance interest savings). The ad we saw had an estimated monthly payment of $80.
  • PayPal Cashback Mastercard® – with a $300 early use cash bonus and 3% cash back on purchases.
  • High limit personal loans that take minutes to apply and to be funded.
  • Banks acting alone or in partnership with a fintech to offer online checking accounts with new account opening bonuses ranging from $300-$600.
  • and of course, Quicken® Mortgage promoting low rates and fast and seamless origination.

These are just a few recent examples from thousands of offers that are reaching your ideal member. Besides offering great rates, cash back, low fees and seamless service – these offers are guided by robust data analytics and consumer segmentation to reach and engage a well-defined, ideal consumer.

Why it matters

The 2020 race is on. Hopefully your team has clarity of the member(s) they want to reach, access to robust data analytics, in depth consumer insights, reliable credit resources and marketing tools they will need to compete in the toughest financial market any of us have likely ever seen.

If you’re afraid that you can’t afford the right tools when it comes to marketing, consider what the dealer fee is for purchasing an indirect auto loan. What if the 2% or more fee was reallocated to finding organic loan growth with consumers you’re more likely to build a relationship with? Or consider the cost of consistently marketing to the wrong consumer segments with the wrong message, at the wrong time and in the wrong channels. What if you could increase your market engagement rate from 5% to 10%?

Perhaps the best strategic question is can you afford NOT to have the best tools that support future membership growth? If you don’t win your ideal member, somebody else will.

Learn More

About Scott Butterfield, CUDE, CCUE

Principal, Your Credit Union Partner

Scott Butterfield is a trusted advisor to the leaders of more than 170 credit unions located throughout the United States. A respected veteran of the CU Movement, he understands the challenges and opportunities facing credit unions today. Scott believes that credit unions matter, and that consumers and small businesses need credit unions to now more than ever.

Related Posts

Why Innovation Matters for Members First Credit Union

Learn how Members First Credit Union uses innovation and data-driven insights to better serve members and expand financial opportunity.

July 24, 2026 by Scarlet Nickel
Ask the Expert: Unlocking the ROI of alternative data with Natasha Madan and Julius Heim

A visibility gap lenders can't afford to ignore Alternative data is often associated with thin-file or credit invisible consumers. But its value extends far beyond those segments. Experian's Clarity Services database includes approximately one in five credit-active consumers, including one in four consumers with prime-and-above credit profiles. That means lenders may be missing important signals, not only for emerging borrowers, but also for applicants who appear well qualified using traditional bureau data alone. Consider two consumers with the same credit score. Based on traditional credit data, they may appear equally creditworthy. But when Clarity data is added, one consumer may demonstrate stable repayment behavior while another shows recent defaults on alternative finance products. The credit score hasn't changed, but the decisioning context has. That's where alternative data creates value: helping lenders distinguish between consumers who look similar on paper but represent very different levels of risk and opportunity. In this Ask the Expert session, Experian’s Julius Heim, Vice President of Analytics Product Build, Innovation and Scores, and Natasha Madan, Senior Director, Analytics Consulting, explain how different alternative data assets solve different business challenges and why the greatest return comes from using them together throughout the credit lifecycle. What that visibility gap is really costing lenders Better visibility matters because every lending decision carries consequences. Without alternative data, lenders may approve applicants whose repayment behavior suggests elevated risk but isn't reflected in a traditional credit file. Without cash flow insights, they may decline consumers who appear thin file on bureau data despite demonstrating strong income and responsible financial management. The result is a two-sided cost: avoidable bad debt on one side and missed growth opportunities on the other. But ROI extends beyond approvals alone. It also appears through stronger marketing strategies, improved conversion, reduced friction and more precise risk segmentation throughout the lending lifecycle. "ROI can mean many things ... marketing to the right people, achieving better approval rates, reducing risk, getting less friction and overall profitability."Julius Heim, Vice President of Analytics Product Build, Innovation and Scores Where alternative data creates ROI Improve approval strategies Use additional consumer signals to recover creditworthy applicants while avoiding unnecessary declines. Reduce portfolio risk Identify elevated repayment risk earlier through enhanced visibility beyond traditional bureau data. Improve portfolio performance Increase conversion, reduce friction and strengthen profitability across the credit lifecycle. Different data. Different jobs. Not all alternative data solves the same problem. Clarity Services can help lenders strengthen decisions early in the customer journey. It provides additional visibility during prospecting and acquisition, helping identify potential risk before an application moves through the underwriting process. Cash flow insights can provide value in a different way. When traditional credit information offers part of the picture, consumer-permissioned cash flow data can provide greater insight into income, spending patterns and financial capacity. That makes it especially valuable as a second look during underwriting. Together, these complementary data assets help lenders improve decisioning throughout the credit lifecycle. They can support acquisition, underwriting, account management and collections while building on the trusted foundation of traditional bureau data. Research also continues to demonstrate measurable lift when cash flow insights are combined with traditional credit information. "I recently did a study with a client where we actually saw a 20% lift in KS [Kolmogorov-Smirnov] above and beyond credit bureau data. Again, the bureau data itself was very predictive. But even from the cash flow data, we still got a 20% lift, which is an amazing stat." Julius Heim, Vice President of Analytics Product Build, Innovation and Scores The greatest value comes from using these data sources together for a more holistic consumer view. Start with proof, then build Adopting alternative data doesn't have to begin with a large transformation. A practical first step is a data study. By comparing current decision strategies with enhanced data, lenders can identify where additional visibility creates measurable lift within their own portfolios. This approach allows institutions to validate results before making broader operational changes. Every lender has different workflows, technology environments and business priorities. A flexible implementation strategy helps organizations incorporate new data in ways that support existing processes rather than disrupting them. Three ways to get started Run a data study Benchmark current decision strategies and quantify potential lift. Start simple Begin with targeted data attributes or proven scores before expanding to more advanced use cases. Build with confidence Scale implementation based on measured business outcomes and organizational priorities. This approach allows lenders to validate results, build confidence and expand their strategy over time. Explore alternative data with a trusted partner Every lending decision benefits from better consumer insight. Experian helps lenders combine trusted credit data with alternative data, cash flow insights and advanced analytics to strengthen decisioning, improve portfolio performance and uncover new opportunities for growth. Whether you're evaluating alternative data for the first time or expanding an existing strategy, Experian can help you identify where additional consumer insight can create measurable business value. Learn more Contact us About our experts Julius Heim Vice President of Analytics Product Build, Innovation and Scores, Experian Julius Heim works at the intersection of financial services, analytics and innovation. He focuses on leveraging data to drive smarter decision-making and support more inclusive financial ecosystems. Julius brings a practical perspective on how organizations can translate insights into real-world impact, with particular interest in emerging trends across fintech, credit, and the use of alternative data, such as cash-flow data, across the credit lifecycle. Previously, he served as Head of Analytics on the lender side and held roles in insurance analytics earlier in his career. Natasha Madan Senior Director, Analytics Consulting, Experian Natasha Madan partners with lenders to drive smarter, data-driven credit and risk decisions. She specializes in leveraging alternative data and advanced analytics to help organizations improve portfolio performance, optimize customer acquisition, and expand responsible access to credit. During her 15 years at Experian, Natasha has held leadership roles spanning data analytics, product analytics and consulting, giving her a broad perspective of how data can be leverage to solve complex business challenges. She has worked with a diverse range of lenders – including banks, credit unions, fintechs and specialty finance companies to develop analytics strategies that optimize customer acquisition, underwriting and portfolio management. Natasha is passionate about helping organizations unlock the full potential of data to improve both business outcomes and consumer financial inclusion.

July 24, 2026 by Julie.JLee@experian.com
Advancing Homeownership Through Partnership 

Learn how HomeFree-USA and Experian partner to expand financial education, strengthen communities and help consumers achieve homeownership.

July 22, 2026 by Scarlet Nickel