Credit Advice

Settled account status more important than who closed the account

Have a question?

Do you have a question about consumer credit? You may find an immediate answer by using the search engine. If you can't find what you're looking for, please fill out the form, being as specific as possible.

Please note: The Ask Experian team cannot respond to each question individually. However, if your question is of interest to a wide audience of consumers, the Experian team will include it in a future column.

Our policies
The information contained in this column if for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. You should consult your own attorney or seek specific advice from a legal professional regarding your particular situation.

Please understand that Experian policies change over time. Column responses reflect Experian policy at the time of writing. While maintained for your information, archived responses may not reflect current Experian policy.

Credit Advice

Settled account status more important than who closed the account

Dear Experian,

How bad does it affect your credit when a creditor reports an account closed by consumer and settled for less then the balance owed?

- NIC

Dear NIC,

There are two issues in your question. The first is who closed the account. The second is the payment status.

Exactly who requested that the account be closed was important in the past. If the lender closed the account, it was seen as negative because that typically happened only when there was some problem with the account. It wasn’t negative if the consumer closed the account because that usually did not reflect any payment problems.

That has changed in recent years. Today, it doesn’t matter who closed the account. People now open and close accounts so frequently that who closed the account typically isn’t considered by creditors when evaluating lending risk.

Credit scoring systems have been adjusted over time to reflect such changes in consumer behavior and in the credit market. The most important issue is whether the account was always paid on time and as agreed before it was closed.

That brings me to the second issue. Settling an account is quite negative.

This question is being raised frequently of late and I am concerned that collection agencies may be advising consumers to settle and giving them the impression that it makes their credit history positive.

When you settle an account, you negotiate to close the account by paying less than originally agreed. Any time you fail to pay the full amount owed it will reflect negatively in your credit report and in credit scores.

If you settle, it does end the collection activity and lets you start focusing on other debts you may owe, but it doesn’t make the negative history go away.

The most important thing you can do to demonstrate creditworthiness and, therefore, to improve credit scores is to pay all of your bills in full and on time.

Thanks for asking.

- The "Ask Experian" team

  • © 2014 Experian Information Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.