Loading...

Is there a formula for success when building portfolio-specific models?

July 30, 2009 by Guest Contributor

By: Wendy Greenawalt

When consulting with lenders, we are frequently asked what credit attributes are most predictive and valuable when developing models and scorecards. Because we receive this request often, we recently decided to perform the arduous analysis required to determine if there are material differences in the attribute make up of a credit risk model based on the portfolio on which it is applied.

The process we used to identify the most predictive attributes was a combination of art and sciences — for which our data experts drew upon their extensive data bureau experience and knowledge obtained through engagements with clients from all types of industries. In addition, they applied an empirical process which provided statistical analysis and validation of the credit attributes included. Next, we built credit risk models for a variety of portfolios including bankcard, mortgage and auto and compared the credit attribute included in each.

What we found is that there are some attributes that are inherently predictive regardless for which portfolio the model was being developed. However, when we took the analysis one step further, we identified that there can be significant differences in the account-level data when comparing different portfolio models.

This discovery pointed to differences, not just in the behavior captured with the attributes, but in the mix of account designations included in the model. For example, in an auto risk model, we might see a mix of attributes from all trades, auto, installment and personal finance…as compared to a bankcard risk model which may be mainly comprised of bankcard, mortgage, student loan and all trades.  Additionally, the attribute granularity included in the models may be quite different, from specific derogatory and public record data to high level account balance or utilization characteristics.

What we concluded is that it is a valuable exercise to carefully analyze available data and consider all the possible credit attribute options in the model-building process – since substantial incremental lift in model performance can be gained from accounts and behavior that may not have been previously considered when assessing credit risk.

Related Posts

Today’s changing economy is directly impacting consumers’ financial behaviors, with some individuals doing well and some showing signs of...

November 14, 2022 by Theresa Nguyen

With consumers having more credit options than ever before, it’s imperative for lenders to get their message in front...

October 10, 2022 by Theresa Nguyen

Learn how you can use credit attributes to identify qualified prospects, set initial limits, manage credit lines and limit credit losses. Read more!

May 24, 2022 by Laura Burrows